New Game: Most important #?

[nmtg9]

This is inspired by seeing Showcase 22 in the 1 to 365 thread.

 

i'll start with (IMHO) the most important #1 comic ie Action #1 (regarded by many as the most important comic published so an easy choice for most important #1)

 

next poster has to say what the most important #2 is and why...

 

then #3 and so on

 

neil

[He11blazer]

2000AD #2

 

First appearance of Judge Dredd

 

 

 

 

Nah, only joking. I'm sure we can think of something rather more fundamental to the world of comics

[conditionfreak]

hmmm.If I say Human Torch #2 (which is actually #1), does that count as #1 or #2?

 

Also, what about #nn's?

[rob_allan]

Whiz Comics #2 gets my vote!

And for #3, Boy Comics #3 (but I'm biased here.)

-Rob-

[Mac Man]

I don't know about most important, but 1 is the loneliest...

[conditionfreak]

I'm pretty sure that #1 and #27 are obvious. It should be interesting what comes up in the other numbers.

 

For #4, maybe FF #4. I don't believe Silver Surfer #4 is as "good" a choice. I say FF #4.

[DiceX]

I don't know about most important, but 1 is the loneliest...

 

Two can be as bad as one.

It's the loneliest number since the number one.

 

 

[ashrael]

I did something similar with 1-100 first appearances at http://boards.collectors-society.com/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Main=74527&Number=1363540#Post1363540

[mica]

FF48

 

[Flee-Marquette]

I don't know about most important, but 1 is the loneliest...

 

Two can be as bad as one.

It's the loneliest number since the number one.

 

Its just no good anymore since you went away...

Now I spend my time making rhymes of yesterday...

 

 

3 should be Suspense #3?

[conditionfreak]

I have never owned Suspense #3, but I have heard that it is all about the cover and no substance inside.

[Scrooge]

3 should be Suspense #3?

 

All-Star # 3

[JazzMan]

181

 

Wolverine's first full appearance

Elektra's "Death" in Daredevil

[toro]

FF #5 1st Doc Doom

[jordanscott]

More than 10 posts and nobody has yet said '69'?

 

Come on guys...yer slippin!

[ashrael]

More than 10 posts and nobody has yet said '69'?

 

Come on guys...yer slippin!

 

69: 1st Sandy the Golden Boy (Adventure Comics)

[JazzMan]

181

 

Wolverine's first full appearance

Elektra's "Death" in Daredevil

 

And I forgot Batman 181 - First Poison Ivy

[Theagenes]

3 should be Suspense #3?

 

All-Star # 3

 

My personal favorite would be Famous Funnies 3 (1st Buck Rogers ), but clearly All-Star 3 is the most important #3 hands down. Suspense 3 is a great cover but hardly an important book.

[Theagenes]

Avengers 4? :shrug:

 

or Showcase 4?

[Scrooge]

Avengers 4? :shrug:

 

Agreed. (thumbs u