The 2010 Nik Memorial Grading Contest *Round 10*

[Mr. Zipper]

Wow. I gave it an 8.0 and I thought that was a 7.5 bump.

 

I find that I almost can't overgrade in this contest.

[Arcade]

I'll take the 3 points. I said 8.5

[comicdonna]

I gave it a 8.5

[oakman29]

Nice I said 9.2,I'll take the three points.Whew!

[cheetah]

[Hibou]

So that wasn't a rip in the logo box...

[Old Fashion PB and J]

wtf? you guys said there was foxing on the back cover.

+1 obviously it was discoloration. I say BOO

[mikenyc]

i thought that was a tear under the price by Thor's head

[joe_collector]

So that wasn't a rip in the logo box...

 

Nope, it was a crease, at least to my eyes.

[dwip99]

Thats gonna hurt. The foxing didn't do a good enough job of bringing the grade down. "Bad foxing..Bad"

[Green]

wtf? you guys said there was foxing on the back cover.

+1 obviously it was discoloration. I say BOO

You guys cant fox with me.

[Old Fashion PB and J]

I gave it a 7.0. Obviously I will ignore comments in the future.

[mikenyc]

6.5 goodbye sweet sweet 91st place

[DiceX]

6.5 goodbye sweet sweet 91st place

 

There's a reason you're in 91st place.

 

 

[Mr. Zipper]

Foxing stains aside, the URFC and LRFC are really soft... and the spine corners are pretty fuzzy for a 9.0.

 

I could understand 8.5 tops, but 9.0...

[skypinkblu]

I bumped it up to 7.5 from 7.0...I figured the corners were bad, too...

 

I think I need to go on the "buy from" list, .

[joe_collector]

Wow, how are you guys going so low? I'm seeing 9.6's coming out of CGC lately that look like 9.2's and even with foxing and that top-left crease, 8.5-9.2 would seem to be the correct range.

[mikenyc]

6.5 goodbye sweet sweet 91st place

 

There's a reason you're in 91st place.

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

6.5 goodbye sweet sweet 91st place

 

There's a reason you're in 91st place.

 

 

[mikenyc]

Wow, how are you guys going so low? I'm seeing 9.6's coming out of CGC lately that look like 9.2's and even with foxing and that top-left crease, 8.5-9.2 would seem to be the correct range.

 

I really thought that was a tear in the logo box.