• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

What is considered High Grade?
0

Started by Ajl007,

168 posts in this topic

Dr1970-migration

Dr1970-migration

Posted
Posted
If you can figure out how to.

 

No sir, I would not like to take the time to figure out why you are such a loser.

 

It is probably because your parents left that coat hanger mark on your forehead before you were born.

 

I kid, I kid. (:

 

But I did ask a real question that you deflected with this stuff: if there is one copy of a Golden Age book in existence, and that book is coverless, do you consider it high grade?

I would...if it was never intended to have a cover.

 

Let's say it was intended to have a cover.

 

Are you letting yourself get sucked back into this argument Richard? I remember the first time, you were left looking pretty silly.

We all look silly at some point. At least you have cute kids. I wonder how that happened? hm

 

Sharon already told you, my wife is hot! (You should see the boys dressed as Wolverine and The Hulk for FCBD. My 6 month old is 22 pounds!)

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Flaming_Telepath

Flaming_Telepath

Posted
Posted
If you can figure out how to.

 

No sir, I would not like to take the time to figure out why you are such a loser.

 

It is probably because your parents left that coat hanger mark on your forehead before you were born.

 

I kid, I kid. (:

 

But I did ask a real question that you deflected with this stuff: if there is one copy of a Golden Age book in existence, and that book is coverless, do you consider it high grade?

I would...if it was never intended to have a cover.

 

Let's say it was intended to have a cover.

 

Are you letting yourself get sucked back into this argument Richard? I remember the first time, you were left looking pretty silly.

We all look silly at some point. At least you have cute kids. I wonder how that happened? hm

 

It's the missus. :gossip:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
MrBedrock

MrBedrock

Posted
Posted
If you can figure out how to.

 

No sir, I would not like to take the time to figure out why you are such a loser.

 

It is probably because your parents left that coat hanger mark on your forehead before you were born.

 

I kid, I kid. (:

 

But I did ask a real question that you deflected with this stuff: if there is one copy of a Golden Age book in existence, and that book is coverless, do you consider it high grade?

I would...if it was never intended to have a cover.

 

Let's say it was intended to have a cover.

 

Are you letting yourself get sucked back into this argument Richard? I remember the first time, you were left look pretty silly.

Actually my argument wasn't made very well, but I still stand by it. If, in the case of a specific book, all copies were damaged during printing, then regardless of it's technical CGC grade there can be high grade copies. My particular examples are Fawcett Movie Comics Man From Planet X (all copies had split spines off the press so the highest CGC grade is probably going to be a 3.0 or so) and Raw Magazine #2? (all copies had a corner torn off by the print staff and reattached to a different copy with tape so how the heck do you grade that?).

Link to comment
Share on other sites
mikenyc

mikenyc

Posted
Posted
If you can figure out how to.

 

No sir, I would not like to take the time to figure out why you are such a loser.

 

It is probably because your parents left that coat hanger mark on your forehead before you were born.

 

I kid, I kid. (:

 

But I did ask a real question that you deflected with this stuff: if there is one copy of a Golden Age book in existence, and that book is coverless, do you consider it high grade?

 

You really need to know your audience when using abortion jokes, personally I chuckled, but I can see infants being offended.

 

I don't understand how this is an argument. I can see arguing subjective points but this is actually objective. Rarity clearly has absolutely nothing to do with it.

 

If you want to waste your time, masturbate to Bea Arthur porn. (shrug)

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guardian Comics

Guardian Comics

Posted
Posted (edited)
I am looking at this from a Census standpoint, many boardies have their opinion as what is HG, but a 9.2 modern is not HG or maybe even copper age and late bronze, but if a book is hard to find in HG based on the book itself would you then adjust to what the highest grade for that book. 9.6-9.0, 9.8-9.2 or based on the number of copies exists 9.0 and above for Bronze age and older book.

 

 

I call that the old school model. zzz

 

I am of the opinion of new school thinking of what HG is partly because of CGC and population in the census of the books. :idea:

 

 

That's not old/new school thinking, I think that's silly school thinking. If I didn't know how smart Ketterer and Siman were, I'd be really afraid for the Philadelphia schooling system :baiting:

 

:hi:

 

Jim

Edited by cgcworld
Link to comment
Share on other sites
NewWorldOrder

NewWorldOrder

Posted
Posted
I am looking at this from a Census standpoint, many boardies have their opinion as what is HG, but a 9.2 modern is not HG or maybe even copper age and late bronze, but if a book is hard to find in HG based on the book itself would you then adjust to what the highest grade for that book. 9.6-9.0, 9.8-9.2 or based on the number of copies exists 9.0 and above for Bronze age and older book.

 

 

I call that the old school model. zzz

 

I am of the opinion of new school thinking of what HG is partly because of CGC and population in the census of the books. :idea:

 

 

That's not old/new school thinking, I think that's silly school thinking. If I didn't know how smart Ketterer and Siman were, I'd be really afraid for the Philadelphia schooling system :baiting:

 

:hi:

 

Jim

 

Call me already you Jimbo. :hi:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
MrBedrock

MrBedrock

Posted
Posted
My particular examples are Fawcett Movie Comics Man From Planet X (all copies had split spines off the press so the highest CGC grade is probably going to be a 3.0 or so)

 

The answer is simple: there are no high grade copies of this book in existence.

wrong...

fawcettmovie15fc.jpg

fawcettmovie15bc.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites
seanfingh

seanfingh

Posted
Posted
If you can figure out how to.

 

That is Sho'Nuff funny.

 

Hey now, I'll never hit the heights of hilarity that Bug/BlackHeartedDwarf/ShoNuff did. He was the master!

 

Well, I can always hope. Why did you can Bropper? That was awesome.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guardian Comics

Guardian Comics

Posted
Posted
I am looking at this from a Census standpoint, many boardies have their opinion as what is HG, but a 9.2 modern is not HG or maybe even copper age and late bronze, but if a book is hard to find in HG based on the book itself would you then adjust to what the highest grade for that book. 9.6-9.0, 9.8-9.2 or based on the number of copies exists 9.0 and above for Bronze age and older book.

 

 

I call that the old school model. zzz

 

I am of the opinion of new school thinking of what HG is partly because of CGC and population in the census of the books. :idea:

 

 

That's not old/new school thinking, I think that's silly school thinking. If I didn't know how smart Ketterer and Siman were, I'd be really afraid for the Philadelphia schooling system :baiting:

 

:hi:

 

Jim

 

Call me already you Jimbo. :hi:

 

You missed another Epic con this weekend, that's two in a row buddy.

 

Jim

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Dr1970-migration

Dr1970-migration

Posted
Posted
If you can figure out how to.

 

That is Sho'Nuff funny.

 

Hey now, I'll never hit the heights of hilarity that Bug/BlackHeartedDwarf/ShoNuff did. He was the master!

 

Well, I can always hope. Why did you can Bropper? That was awesome.

 

Wasn't me (honestly). I only have one at a time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
NewWorldOrder

NewWorldOrder

Posted
Posted
I am looking at this from a Census standpoint, many boardies have their opinion as what is HG, but a 9.2 modern is not HG or maybe even copper age and late bronze, but if a book is hard to find in HG based on the book itself would you then adjust to what the highest grade for that book. 9.6-9.0, 9.8-9.2 or based on the number of copies exists 9.0 and above for Bronze age and older book.

 

 

I call that the old school model. zzz

 

I am of the opinion of new school thinking of what HG is partly because of CGC and population in the census of the books. :idea:

 

 

That's not old/new school thinking, I think that's silly school thinking. If I didn't know how smart Ketterer and Siman were, I'd be really afraid for the Philadelphia schooling system :baiting:

 

:hi:

 

Jim

 

Call me already you Jimbo. :hi:

 

You missed another Epic con this weekend, that's two in a row buddy.

 

Jim

 

Well once these fraudulent gas prices come down I will go next year.

 

Cheapest flight of $500+ from San Diego to Detroit is not helping me spend money in the Motor City.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Dr1970-migration

Dr1970-migration

Posted
Posted
My particular examples are Fawcett Movie Comics Man From Planet X (all copies had split spines off the press so the highest CGC grade is probably going to be a 3.0 or so)

 

The answer is simple: there are no high grade copies of this book in existence.

wrong...

 

If the highest grade of this book in existence is and will always be a 3.0, then there are no high grade copies in existence. This was what I was talking about when I said you looked silly. Please stop it, you aren't is SOT's league, as you usually say smart things.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Ajl007

Ajl007

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

Thanks everyone for clarifying this question now I think we all need to be friends and have a drink.

ObamaOsama4.jpg

 

SOT I should have listened to you about this topic!

Edited by Ajl007
Link to comment
Share on other sites
NewWorldOrder

NewWorldOrder

Posted
Posted
My particular examples are Fawcett Movie Comics Man From Planet X (all copies had split spines off the press so the highest CGC grade is probably going to be a 3.0 or so)

 

The answer is simple: there are no high grade copies of this book in existence.

wrong...

 

If the highest grade of this book is a 3.0, then there are no high grade copies in existence. This was what I was talking about when I said you looked silly. Please stop it, you aren't is SOT's league, as you usually say smart things.

 

Funny how you call me SOT, as I would rather you just call me d-bag.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
0
Go to topic listing