~~THE~~GIVING~~TREE~~ 5 5

[Kystix]

Added more to my offer:

My offer is:

• Web of Spiderman 1
  
• Superior Spiderman 1 sketch variant
  
• Superior Spiderman 29
  
• Amazing Spiderman 200
  
• Amazing Spiderman 194 - PGM thread
  
• Amazing Spiderman 66
  
• Amazing Spiderman 67 - bought off of 1cool for $67 as a VF/NM

 

 

 

 

To view the 300dpi scanned images follow the directions found here

 

 

[Kystix]

Hey Harvey, What is the current offer?

 

Dats Bait.

[ChrisInBaltimore]

It's funny because Harvey posted something after I said that. He deleted it before the page loaded though... I was hoping it was the guy destroying the computer.

[kav]

No it was

[1Cool]

Kav - you are going to wait for the perfect offer even though a huge batch of people will be able to take an offer again in a couple days. These same people beat you to an offer last time. What do you plan to do differently this time?

Edited August 3, 2014 by 1Cool

[The_Drek_Police]

[kav]

No I could have snagged most of those offers but chose to let others have them.

[BarryAllen]

Kav - you are going to wait for the perfect offer even though a huge batch of people will be able to take an offer again in a couple days. These same people beat you to an offer last time. What do you plan to do differently this time?

 

this feels like a question for a job interview...

 

FYI - the fact that a "huge batch" of people are waiting to be able to take offers is interesting...

[Jiminy_Cricket-migration]

Hector did a great job in making multiple options and switching up his offers frequently for everyone. Excellent effort, Hector.

[Unca Ben]

that ASM 67 is an awfully sweet book.

[Scturo]

Maybe a slab option would help? Slabs don't seem to last long.

[bababooey]

just for clarification purposes-- if someone who is on the 30 day clock uses the 48 hour rule to claim the latest item, does that reset their clock to 30 days from the latest claim?

 

You're asking if you claimed something on July 4th and can't claim something again until August 4th, BUT claim something via the 48 Hour Exception on July 15th, is your 30 day period extended until August 15th?

 

No.

 

The 48 Hour Exception does not change your waiting period.

This is your thread so it's your rules but I'll just point this out, because you may or may not have considered it.

 

Items taken after 48 hour rule

Scenario A - Recent "taker" grabs something after 48 hours, clock doesn't reset

Scenario B - New "taker" grabs something after 48 hours, they get put on the sidelines for 30 days

 

If you're saying only items taken within the first 48 hours count for everybody's clocks - which might help all offers move on day 3 - then that rule makes sense....but the way I'm interpreting your stated clock rules seems to favor "frequent flyers".

 

 

[bababooey]

 

I'll get this out of the way.

 

[Jiminy_Cricket-migration]

 

[Unca Ben]

...but then the Scenario B guy gets to take anything after 48 hrs as well. He's only sidelined for 30 days just like the Scenario A guy was in the first place.

 

I'm not seeing how it favors anybody

[jsilverjanet]

Hector did a great job in making multiple options and switching up his offers frequently for everyone. Excellent effort, Hector.

 

[Shadow Images]

 

I'll get this out of the way.

 

 

 

You sure have a lot of opinion on a thread you have not participated in.

[jsilverjanet]

 

I'll get this out of the way.

 

 

 

You sure have a lot of opinion on a thread you have not participated in.

[bababooey]

...but then the Scenario B guy gets to take anything after 48 hrs as well. He's only sidelined for 30 days just like the Scenario A guy was in the first place.

 

I'm not seeing how it favors anybody

I'm just not sure how Harvey meant 8 (b) to be interpreted.

 

I'm saying that the Scenario B guy shouldn't get the month long 48 hour restriction if the frequent flyers don't roll forward.

 

That would be equal treatment, how is this unclear?

 

The fair alternative is to roll forward the frequent flyers based on their most recent 48 hour "take".

[DiamondCityComics]

It seems to me if this Spiderman offer isn't what a single person considers worth grabbing this thread has pretty much been narrowed down to those that have already participated. Could be wrong but I'm thinking people really are afraid to grab something.