Cerebus 1 a more valuable key than Hulk 181? Really Overstreet? Poll on Page 87 3 3

[chrisco37]

What's keeping Crime SuspenStories 22 relevant?

 

SOTI book, classic cover

 

Lot's of PCH fans/collectors and this has always been one of the "trophies".

Edited September 5, 2014 by chrisco37

[bronze johnny]

What's keeping Crime SuspenStories 22 relevant?

 

SOTI book, classic cover

 

Lot's of PCH fans/collectors and this has always been one of the "trophies".

 

Do you think a Cerebus 1 in 9.2 is more valuable than a 9.2 CSS 22?

[Ryan.]

What's keeping Crime SuspenStories 22 relevant?

 

SOTI book, classic cover

 

Lot's of PCH fans/collectors and this has always been one of the "trophies".

 

So, basically, for more reasons than just having a featured character in popular media.

 

Edited September 5, 2014 by Ryan.

[chrisco37]

What's keeping Crime SuspenStories 22 relevant?

 

SOTI book, classic cover

 

Lot's of PCH fans/collectors and this has always been one of the "trophies".

 

Do you think a Cerebus 1 in 9.2 is more valuable than a 9.2 CSS 22?

 

Probably

[HighStakesComics]

What's keeping Crime SuspenStories 22 relevant?

 

SOTI book, classic cover

 

Lot's of PCH fans/collectors and this has always been one of the "trophies".

 

Do you think a Cerebus 1 in 9.2 is more valuable than a 9.2 CSS 22?

 

Probably

 

I typically agree with your posts, but this is a reach. CSS 22 in 9.2 would probably fetch at least $8,000, and that is a conservative number. I think an 8.5 sold for $7k within the last few months. A Cerebus 9.4 or 9.6 would be more comparable. A 9.2 would get annihilated.

[chrisco37]

What's keeping Crime SuspenStories 22 relevant?

 

SOTI book, classic cover

 

Lot's of PCH fans/collectors and this has always been one of the "trophies".

 

Do you think a Cerebus 1 in 9.2 is more valuable than a 9.2 CSS 22?

 

Probably

 

I typically agree with your posts, but this is a reach. CSS 22 in 9.2 would probably fetch at least $8,000, and that is a conservative number. I think an 8.5 sold for $7k within the last few months. A Cerebus 9.4 or 9.6 would be more comparable. A 9.2 would get annihilated.

 

Yeah, I thought it would, but I haven't bought any PCH in quite awhile so I just have no idea what the market for it is.

[Petey's Wheatcake]

What's keeping Crime SuspenStories 22 relevant?

 

SOTI book, classic cover

 

Lot's of PCH fans/collectors and this has always been one of the "trophies".

 

So, basically, for more reasons than just having a featured character in popular media.

 

 

I see what you did there.

[seanfingh]

What's keeping Crime SuspenStories 22 relevant?

 

SOTI book, classic cover

 

Lot's of PCH fans/collectors and this has always been one of the "trophies".

 

So, basically, for more reasons than just having a featured character in popular media.

 

 

I see what you did there.

 

Your Username is frickin' awesome. I still remember the first time I read a reprint of AF15 and thought in my 5 year old mind - "What the F is a wheatcake?"

[Petey's Wheatcake]

Haha. Thank you. That's exactly what I thought the first time I read Origins of Marvel Comics.

 

I still annoy my kids to this day when I offer my them wheatcakes for breakfast.

 

My son also requests that I don't refer to him as a milksop in public, but I can't help it.

[bronze johnny]

Let me also say that your user name is awesome (thumbs u

[bronze johnny]

This is the 100 Page Super Spectacular Page of this thread! Let's get 5 posts for this page so we can call this "100 Page SS # 5."

[hippiecop]

I find the Petey's Wheatcake name annoying. But the reason it's annoying is because I didn't think of it first...

[seanfingh]

I find the Petey's Wheatcake name annoying. But the reason it's annoying is because I didn't think of it first...

 

{tossles hair}

[porcupine48]

I am in shock and awe...

[HighStakesComics]

This is the 100 Page Super Spectacular Page of this thread! Let's get 5 posts for this page so we can call this "100 Page SS # 5."

 

I may be ruining my life but I just can't help myself.

[bronze johnny]

This thread does wonders for the Cerebrum.

[chrisco37]

This thread does wonders for the Cerebrum.

 

You've been banging your head against the wall too?

[bronze johnny]

This thread does wonders for the Cerebrum.

 

You've been banging your head against the wall too?

 

Hasn't everyone here?

[Petey's Wheatcake]

I find the Petey's Wheatcake name annoying. But the reason it's annoying is because I didn't think of it first...

 

Thank you, bronzejohnny and hippiecop. Such kind words, and you saved them for the 100 Page Super Spectacular!

 

I think anyone who compliments me displays an aptitude for sound, logical reasoning, an unbiased understanding of all the relevant facts, and an extremely high level of class and sophistication.

 

Okay, so who is going to start the "What will the Overstreet 2019 Top Ten List Look Like?" thread? I have a feeling that blazincomics has an opinion or two on this.

[bronze johnny]

I find the Petey's Wheatcake name annoying. But the reason it's annoying is because I didn't think of it first...

 

Thank you, bronzejohnny and hippiecop. Such kind words, and you saved them for the 100 Page Super Spectacular!

 

I think anyone who compliments me displays an aptitude for sound, logical reasoning, an unbiased understanding of all the relevant facts, and an extremely high level of class and sophistication.

 

Okay, so who is going to start the "What will the Overstreet 2019 Top Ten List Look Like?" thread? I have a feeling that blazincomics has an opinion or two on this.

 

 

I was just about to raise the question about whether Overstreet will place Hulk 181 above Cerebus 1 especially after Jay's fantastic analysis.