2016 March Madness Comic Grading Tournament - Round of 128

[stanley1883]

Haunted is whites out?

[jaybuck43]

hope my round was strong enough. I think I put up 73.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

spidermanbeyond 37-1 [-20]

BYE [-20]

 

byosti 18-6 [90]

drewincanada 18-7 [78]

 

Thanos88 22-5 [75]

fiberbiskit 11-8 [67]

 

Mike's Rack 20-4 [55]

Plantman 12-10 [62]

 

Revat 23-6 [58]

iceman399 16-9 [93]

 

1Cool 20-3 [68]

paradigmcomics 10-11 [48]

 

marmat 16-5 [67]

MetalPSI 18-9 [35]

 

B3AST 29-4 [-20]

BYE [-20]

 

canickus 39-3 [-20]

BYE [-20]

 

Amazing Spidey 23-8 [95]

AJD 14-6 [71]

 

Jeffro 27-6 [53]

toro 13-9 [95]

 

letsgrumble 23-4 [43]

Paddy_McShillihan 12-11 [62]

 

zuulioso 19-5 [59]

SpideyFein 15-9 [75]

 

Ron Rau 25-4 [51]

BYE [-20]

 

mar-vell 20-6 [58]

Montezuma 16-8 [68]

 

SNiPER 24-3 [-20]

BYE [-20]

 

W16227 29-1 [45]

BYE [-20]

 

eeb03 18-6 [57]

jaybuck43 15-6 [75]

 

thirdgreenham 22-5 [70]

ninanina 14-10 [-20]

 

old dano 31-6 [71]

Silver 14-12 [35]

 

oakman29 23-6 [45]

Dark Knight 14-8 [82]

 

kav 25-4 [45]

IncredibleHauck 0-0 [67]

 

snowman28 20-6 [44]

Grantley Goddard 14-7 [-20]

 

Jollycomics 22-3 [-20]

BYE [-20]

 

DeadOne 31-2 [65]

BYE [-20]

 

Shadow 21-7 [71]

Tempus Fugit 19-8 [-20]

 

SonOfWolF 27-6 [59]

manicnerd 17-12 [56]

 

djpinkpanther67 22-4 [81]

trmoore54 12-11 [67]

 

Azkaban 23-6 [60]

Conan_Aficionado 14-8 [48]

 

John R 25-4 [54]

stanley1883 0-0 [73]

 

Richard The Man 20-6 [47]

cheta42 18-9 [-20]

 

THB 22-3 [42]

BYE [-20]

 

TheGeneral 22-2 [-20]

BYE [-20]

 

Michelangelo 18-7 [47]

jimbo_707 16-7 [93]

 

BorderlineHoarder 22-5 [71]

Unca Scrooge 12-10 [63]

 

HighStakesComics 18-4 [78]

Couchy81 12-11 [44]

 

TrapezeTony 17-5 [63]

mccollect 14-9 [68]

 

LordRahl 29-5 [-20]

BYE [-20]

 

AL Comics 18-6 [95]

MustEatBrains 16-9 [70]

 

Cascaders27 27-4 [58]

BYE [-20]

 

DavidTheDavid 24-3 [35]

BYE [-20]

 

Mio 17-6 [39]

Rogue79 18-8 [29]

 

comicdey 20-5 [47]

collector_bill 14-11 [53]

 

rfoii 20-4 [55]

s-man 10-11 [68]

 

Wilson3d 29-8 [65]

comicdonna 12-8 [65]

 

porky 23-4 [-20]

BYE [-20]

 

wipple 21-7 [47]

Scturo 15-8 [47]

 

Hado 21-3 [-20]

BYE [-20]

 

jhutton2 31-3 [-20]

BYE [-20]

 

jsilverjanet 16-6 [68]

quadman78 16-7 [33]

 

BlackLantern 20-5 [68]

01TheDude 12-10 [78]

 

KryptoMayor 19-4 [53]

jessebrook1 10-10 [58]

 

FutureFlash 18-5 [48]

musicmeta 14-9 [-20]

 

427Impalers 29-5 [50]

BYE [-20]

 

notbrook 18-6 [50]

Fastballspecial 16-9 [58]

 

Warlord 21-3 [-20]

BYE [-20]

 

boatfund 29-3 [-20]

BYE [-20]

 

thunsicker 17-6 [47]

AlexH 18-8 [44]

 

RICK STARR 20-5 [52]

Red84 10-8 [47]

 

pjray55 29-6 [50]

Every Day A Story 12-10 [70]

 

ss5rmp 18-5 [52]

spideyfan76 14-9 [63]

 

jaybes 23-4 [53]

WEBHEAD 12-12 [38]

 

Omaha-CGC-Comics 18-6 [-20]

Columbia Comics 16-9 [66]

 

KPR Comics 21-3 [-20]

BYE [-20]

 

[AL Comics]

I'm not sure how that happened...

[BorderlineHoarder]

Haunted is whites out?

 

It's a 7.0...he left the inner cover grade obscured but you can see the outer cover there.

[1Cool]

Hate books like the Strange Takes Annual. I must have spent 10 minutes debating a 2.0 vs 2.5. Went with a 2.0 due to the tear and chunk missing.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Give me a second to determine who needs to submit grades.

 

 

Overtime book:

 

Small scans:

 

 

 

Large Scans (click on the image twice to get the maximum size):

 

 

 

 

[1Cool]

I'm going to need to do much better next round if I want to stay in. Some fantastic scores out there.

[drewincanada]

Oh my. I'm out. Comicdey is out. Last year's finalists are both gone.

 

Fantastic score, byosti. Good luck the rest of the way!

[Comicdey]

Good luck collector bill. 1 and out this year ::

 

 

Haunted. 5.5.

(Ranged 5.5-6.5 and maybe lower due to tanning but landed at 5.5)

 

ST 1.8

(Ranged 1.8-2.5 but tear and pofc dropped me down)

 

Star Wars 9.0

(wanted to say 9.4-9.6, but multiple substances pulled my grade down to 9.0, could have gone as low as 8.5 but likely 9.2. Landed at 9.0 but want to say higher)

 

Spider-Woman. 9.2Q

(solid book tiny corner bumps and right edge bend, could be lower, but presents well)

 

[eeb03]

eeb03 18-6 [57]

jaybuck43 15-6 [75]

Congratulations on the win jaybuck43.

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Wilson3d 29-8 [65]

comicdonna 12-8 [65]

 

 

wipple 21-7 [47]

Scturo 15-8 [47]

 

 

These are the overtime contestants. I sent out PMs to let them know that grades are due within 24 hours.

 

 

 

Overtime book:

 

Small scans:

 

 

 

Large Scans (click on the image twice to get the maximum size):

 

 

 

 

[Red84]

And I officially lost because I changed my grade on the Star Wars from 9.4 to 8.5

[BlowUpTheMoon]

And I officially lost because I changed my grade on the Star Wars from 9.4 to 8.5

 

tmoore was winning 82 to 81 until he changed his grade on the Star Wars book about 30 minutes ago.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Wilson3d 29-8 [65]

comicdonna 12-8 [65]

 

 

wipple 21-7 [47]

Scturo 15-8 [47]

 

 

These are the overtime contestants. I'll send out PMs in a little bit to let them know that grades are due within 24 hours.

 

wipple has submitted grades

[Wipple]

Wilson3d 29-8 [65]

comicdonna 12-8 [65]

 

 

wipple 21-7 [47]

Scturo 15-8 [47]

 

 

These are the overtime contestants. I'll send out PMs in a little bit to let them know that grades are due within 24 hours.

 

wipple has submitted grades

[Hado]

I was

 

7.5

4.5 way high, no idea why

9.4

9.2

[thirdgreenham]

And I officially lost because I changed my grade on the Star Wars from 9.4 to 8.5

 

tmoore was winning 82 to 81 until he changed his grade on the Star Wars book about 30 minutes ago.

 

poor guy

[trmoore54]

And I officially lost because I changed my grade on the Star Wars from 9.4 to 8.5

 

tmoore was winning 82 to 81 until he changed his grade on the Star Wars book about 30 minutes ago.

 

 

F*@&ing graders notes...hoping next time I submit a book with splooge on the cover I get an upgrade...

 

Would've been my 3rd bullseye with a 1-off on the Haunted...

 

Carry the torch Thomas!!

[drewincanada]

I went:

 

7.0

2.0

9.2

9.2

 

Two bullseyes, .2 off on the third, and .5 off on the fourth, and I was still blown out of the water!