2016 March Madness Comic Grading Tournament - Final

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Here's a book I was planning on including, but didn't think it would be fair.

 

 

 

[W16227]

Here's a book I was planning on including, but didn't think it would be fair.

 

 

 

What was not "fair" - and what did it grade???

[LordRahl]

Here's a book I was planning on including, but didn't think it would be fair.

 

 

 

What was not "fair" - and what did it grade???

 

Looks high grade so I'm guessing there is something that is bringing it down which isn't readily visible in the scan?

[BlowUpTheMoon]

What do you think the grade is?

[Scturo]

Was it trimmed?

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Was it trimmed?

 

Nope.

[LordRahl]

From the small scan... 9.4/9.6

[Plantman]

Here's a book I was planning on including, but didn't think it would be fair.

 

 

 

What was not "fair" - and what did it grade???

 

Looks high grade so I'm guessing there is something that is bringing it down which isn't readily visible in the scan?

 

Or was it...a 9.9?

[427Impaler]

Some funky horizontal line across the top of the front cover...

[comicdonna]

What do you think the grade is?

7.5

[kav]

Grades in.

[Shadow]

Congratulations Lord Rahl! Fun tournament.

[sckao]

[sckao]

 

PRIZE PICKING ORDER

 

Order is determined by Order eliminated in the tournament (unless you're LordRahl).

For example: If you were eliminated in the FINAL FOUR, then your Final Standing is sorted against the other Final Four contestants. (Final standings are how many games you won added to your SEEDING ROUND.)

 

If you did not participate in the SEEDING ROUND, you are automatically dropped to last in that round.

 

TIES are broken by the earliest Bullseye in the SEEDING ROUND. In case of a further tie, the SECOND Earliest Bullseye is counted.

 

I'm not done yet... but let's get this show started...

 

 

1 LordRahl 35-5

2 toro 19-9

 

3 427Impalers 33-5

4 Shadow 26-7

 

5 W16227 32-1

6 Mio 21-6

7 iceman399 20-9

8 Every Day A Story 16-10

 

9 spidermanbeyond 39-1

10 TheGeneral 24-2

11 KPR Comics 23-3

12 Ron Rau 27-4

13 Richard The Man 23-6

14 comicdonna 15-8

15 01TheDude 15-10

16 IncredibleHauck 3-0*

 

17 canickus 40-3

18 jhutton2 32-3

19 boatfund 30-3

20 SNiPER 25-3

21 Cascaders27 28-4

22 jaybes 25-4

23 SonOfWolF 29-6

24 thirdgreenham 24-5 (TIED WINS TB1)

25 BorderlineHoarder 24-5 (TIED WINS TB 2)

26 Thanos88 24-5 (TIED WINS TB 3)

27 Azkaban 25-6

28 snowman28 22-6

29 marmat 18-5

30 wipple 23-7

31 Fastballspecial 18-9

32 s-man 12-11

 

33 DeadOne 31-2

34 DavidTheDavid 24-3

35 THB 22-3 (Tiebreaker)

36 Jollycomics 22-3 (Tiebreaker)

37 Warlord 22-3 (Tiebreaker)

38 B3AST 29-4

39 1Cool 21-3 (Tiebreaker)

40 Hado 21-3 (Tiebreaker)

41 djpinkpanther67 23-4 (Tiebreaker)

42 porky 23-4 (Tiebreaker)

43 old dano 32-6

44 HighStakesComics 19-4

45 RICK STARR 21-5

46 FutureFlash 19-5

47 AL Comics 19-6 (Tiebreaker)

48 byosti 19-6 (Tiebreaker)

49 thunsicker 18-6

50 Amazing Spidey 24-8

51 jsilverjanet 17-6

52 jaybuck43 16-6

53 jimbo_707 17-7

54 Montezuma 17-8

55 Columbia Comics 17-9

56 Dark Knight 15-8

57 SpideyFein 16-9

58 spideyfan76 15-9 (Tiebreaker)

59 mccollect 15-9 (Tiebreaker)

60 collector_bill 15-11

61 Plantman 13-10

62 Paddy_McShillihan 13-11

63 jessebrook1 11-10

64 stanley1883 1-0

 

65 and below.... UNRANKED.

 

 

[toro]

Congrats LordRahl!

 

Thanks to Blowie and sckao, tremendous contest!

 

Thanks for all the hard work that went into the contest. This was a tough round and LordRahl beat the heck out of me.

[kav]

Toro I'm still your #1 fan

[Hado]

When or if my turn comes up I'd like to pass if I could

 

[TheGeneral]

Congrats on the victory LordRahl!

 

Thanks for another awesome Tournament BUTM and sckao!

[spidermanbeyond]

Congrats LordRahl. Amazing Scores throughout the tournament. Well done.

[mar-vell]