• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

2018 Annual March Madness CGC Grading Tournament - Seeding Round
8 8

Started by BlowUpTheMoon,

199 posts in this topic

Black_Adam

Black_Adam

Posted
Posted
1 minute ago, sckao said:

Hmm. I hope you guys are just bad at scoring... Otherwise, there's a problem with the scoring. Comicquant got his right though. hm

If I understand the bonus structure correctly, I scored 29-6? (shrug)

Link to comment
Share on other sites
adampasz

adampasz

Posted
Posted
7 minutes ago, sckao said:

Hmm. I hope you guys are just bad at scoring... Otherwise, there's a problem with the scoring. Comicquant got his right though. hm

Oh yeah. My math was horrible.

Spot on= 3 wins
Within .5= 2 wins
Not within .5 = 1 loss
Not within 1= 2 losses

Bonus= The third spot on grade will be granted 1 bonus win, fourth= 2 bonus wins, fifth through tenth= 3 bonus wins.

ASM 85: Mine 7.5, Actual 8.5 --> +1L
ASM 129: Mine 4.0, Actual 3.5 --> +2W
JLA: Mine 8.5, Actual 8 --> +2W
GL: Mine 9.2, Actual 9.2 --> +3W
PP: Mine 3.5, Actual 4 --> +2W
Toma: Mine 2.0, Actual 2.5 --> +2W
TT: Mine 6.0, Actual 6.5 --> +2W
MF: Mine 5.0, Actual 5.0 --> +3W
SC: Mine 3.0, Actual 0.5 --> +2L
WAR: Mine 7.0, Actual 6 --> +1L

16W 4L

Link to comment
Share on other sites
sckao

sckao

Posted
Posted (edited)

The problem is with BOOK 5 and people who submitted 3.5... BOOK 5 has a special notation on it. (Just saw the spreadsheet this morning...)

 

One sec...

 

Edited by sckao
Link to comment
Share on other sites
sckao

sckao

Posted
Posted

Sorry about that... Apparently, was there a ZERO GRADE book in the seeding round last year? If so, it screwed up this year's book 5 as the formula wasn't changed back to reflect a normal book.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
sckao

sckao

Posted
Posted
SEEDING ROUND RANKING PLAYER PCT
1 1Cool 33-2 0.94
1 szavisca 27-3 0.90
1 toro 27-4 0.87
1 mdean 25-4 0.86
1 TheGeneral 25-5 0.83
1 Black_Adam 29-6 0.83
1 Point Five 18-4 0.82
1 Betty-Bates 21-5 0.81
2 adampasz 16-4 0.80
2 Shadow 15-4 0.79
2 SonOfWolf 15-4 0.79
2 RockMyAmadeus 15-4 0.79
2 larryfk 18-5 0.78
2 s.krank 14-4 0.78
2 Tsp99 23-7 0.77
2 OdinsSecrets 16-5 0.76
3 bighairjer 16-5 0.76
3 DeadOne 19-6 0.76
3 Ron C. 19-7 0.73
3 Azkaban 19-7 0.73
3 LordRahl 16-6 0.73
3 jgallo 16-6 0.73
3 comicquaint 17-7 0.71
3 AJD 19-8 0.70
4 BuscemasAvengers 14-6 0.70
4 thirdgreenham 14-6 0.70
4 Red84 14-6 0.70
4 Action Comics 14-6 0.70
4 Nickelspot 14-6 0.70
4 Chiclenwings 14-6 0.70
4 Michelangelo 16-7 0.70
4 KPR Comics 16-7 0.70
5 AndyFish 17-8 0.68
5 Zalgardos 17-8 0.68
5 djpinkpanther 12-6 0.67
5 01TheDude 16-8 0.67
5 Aces 12-6 0.67
5 THB 14-7 0.67
5 canickus 16-8 0.67
5 BorderlineHoarder 14-7 0.67
6 spidermanbeyond 14-7 0.67
6 T'Challa 14-8 0.64
6 oakman29 14-8 0.64
6 Gsims718 14-8 0.64
6 Lpgk 14-8 0.64
6 Dcman 11-7 0.61
6 kav 12-8 0.60
6 danielortiz 12-8 0.60
7 KryptoMayor 12-8 0.60
7 Murphman13 12-8 0.60
7 jevinuts 12-8 0.60
7 IncredibleHauck 12-8 0.60
7 MustEarBains 12-8 0.60
7 timern 12-8 0.60
7 iuz22000 14-10 0.58
7 eeb03 11-8 0.58
8 Raze 11-8 0.58
8 mcollect 12-9 0.57
8 Sandflea 12-9 0.57
8 old_dano 12-9 0.57
8 WEBHEAD 12-9 0.57
8 427Impaler 12-9 0.57
8 domuhnator 12-9 0.57
8 W16227 10-8 0.56
9 grebel 11-9 0.55
9 iXr184 12-10 0.55
9 Dark Knight 12-10 0.55
9 mattn792 12-10 0.55
9 solm4st3r 10-9 0.53
9 Harry Lime 10-9 0.53
9 AJ0605 10-9 0.53
9 Wipple 10-10 0.50
10 cocomonkey 9-9 0.50
10 youfoundjake 10-10 0.50
10 ADAMANTIUM 10-10 0.50
10 Every Day A Story 10-10 0.50
10 Comics181 9-10 0.47
10 Paddy_McShillihan 10-12 0.45
10 Norinn Radd 9-11 0.45
10 porky 9-11 0.45
11 The Resurrection 8-10 0.44
11 aszumilo 8-10 0.44
11 fastballspecial 8-10 0.44
11 Jester Hats 10-13 0.43
11 Myparentsbasement 8-11 0.42
11 Warlord 7-10 0.41
11 trmoore54 7-12 0.37
11 Jeff Spain 7-12 0.37
12 ss5rmp 6-11 0.35
12 divad 6-11 0.35
12 Mike's Rack 7-13 0.35
12 topcat54 7-13 0.35
12 matmat 7-13 0.35
12 Larryw7 6-12 0.33
12 pjray55 6-12 0.33
12 letsgrumble 6-12 0.33
13 Thanos88 5-11 0.31
13 rat chew 5-15 0.25
13 Amazing Spidey 5-16 0.24
13 John R 4-13 0.24
13 manicnerd 4-13 0.24
13 comic_dave 4-14 0.22
13 Wally's Comics 3-18 0.14
13 inapicklecomics 0-17 0.00
14 0-20 0.00
14 0-20 0.00
14 0-20 0.00
14 0-20 0.00
14 0-20 0.00
14 0-20 0.00
14 0-20 0.00
14 0-20 0.00
15 0-20 0.00
15 0-20 0.00
15 0-20 0.00
15 0-20 0.00
15 0-20 0.00
15 0-20 0.00
15 0-20 0.00
15 0-20 0.00
16 0-20 0.00
16 0-20 0.00
16 0-20 0.00
16 0-20 0.00
16 0-20 0.00
16 0-20 0.00
16 0-20 0.00
16 0-20 0.00
Link to comment
Share on other sites
youfoundjake

youfoundjake

Posted
Posted (edited)

#10 for 10-10 at 50%  ok I guess, and the lesson is to scribble with black sharpies on the defect like @adampasz mentioned.

Not sure what I missed on the Sensation comics, as I had that at a 4.0, but  .5? heeh

 

Oh, now i see the missing centerfold affects story text.. doh!

Edited by youfoundjake
dumabass
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
8 8
Go to topic listing