• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Bmattioli86

Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    216

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Bmattioli86

  1. Bmattioli86
    6.0 for me
  2. Bmattioli86
    I’ll go with 4.0…. Be interested to see how that ring on the BC would react to a press
  3. Bmattioli86
    Grades are in!
  4. Bmattioli86
    3.5 seems to be the cap on this. The tear will automatically put you there
  5. Bmattioli86
    8.0-8.5 thereabouts
  6. Bmattioli86
    7.0
  7. Bmattioli86
    I’m in!
  8. Bmattioli86
    I would be hesitant with this issue. CGC sees this book everyday im sure, and they might grade it harsher due to that fact. I think the most optimistic outcome is likley 8.5, but it can swing either way.
  9. Bmattioli86
    I’ll take a stab at 7.0, just because it presents so nice. Don’t think it’ll get as high as 7.5 but could be wrong.
  10. Bmattioli86
    CGC might grade it lower, with eye appeal I’ll take a shot at 4.5
  11. Bmattioli86
    7.5-8.0
  12. Bmattioli86
    Color rub, micro ticks, and some creases. I’d say 6.5
  13. Bmattioli86
    7.0 WP
  14. Bmattioli86
    4.5 for me
  15. Bmattioli86
    7.0 for me
  16. Bmattioli86
    Not quite sure what the cap is on the tears and missing pieces, so I’ll take a shot at it being 4.0 but could be lower
  17. Bmattioli86
    A c/p will definitely help it out a lot. I’ll take a stab at CGC giving this an 8.0 after c/p
  18. Bmattioli86
    C/P to get a 5.0-5.5 as it stands, probably a 4.5
  19. Bmattioli86
    4.5 for me
  20. Bmattioli86
    5.5 at it stands right now
  21. Bmattioli86
    Whew… 5.0…. That’s a stretch and a half. Seeing as you’ve delt with this seller numerous times, I’m assuming a return is eminent
  22. Bmattioli86
    Don’t have a grade but does it ever look better.. I know where this book comes from
  23. Bmattioli86
    3.0-3.5.. has that top staple been replaced? Looks suspicious.
  24. Bmattioli86
    2.0 for me. With a tear that significant I can’t see it getting any higher. No matter what the back looks like
  25. Bmattioli86
    5.5 as stands, probably higher with a c/p