Grading Contest--with Prize!

[Mio]

#8 isn't bad for my 1st contest. Yay me.

[universal soldier]

I feel really good about a 4th place finish in my first grading contest. Only had one that cost me negative points.

[Boozad]

I did terrible. Mind you I did grade the books in 5 minutes. No excuse

[thirdgreenham]

I made the top 10 (barely)

 

[Theagenes]

Thanks for a great contest!

 

And congrats to byost! Great job!

 

[sniderwj]

That was a good time.. I will have to actually spend quality time and not 15 minutes in front of the TV.

 

Congrats to the winners! (thumbs u

[thehumantorch]

Congrats to those that finished above me, a long list indeed. To those that finished in the 40's and higher I am in awe of your grading skills. byosti, amazing.

[Sal]

can we get a list of all the books with their CGC grades, please?

[143ksk]

Sub-Mariner Comics 14 Fall 1944 Timely Comics Universal 5.0 CREAM TO OFF-WHITE

Archie Comics 2 Spring 1943 MLJ Magazines Universal 2.5 CREAM TO OFF-WHITE

Dizzy Dames 1 9-10/52 American Comics Group Edgar Church (Mile High) Universal 8.5 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE 8.5

Archie Comics 36 1-2/49 MLJ Magazines Universal 7.0 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Archie 167 9/66 Archie Publications Universal 9.4 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Archie's Girls Betty and Veronica 40 1/59 Archie Publications Universal 7.5 OFF-WHITE

Archie's Pal Jughead 103 12/63 Archie Publications Universal 9.6 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Chamber of Chills 19 9/53 Harvey Publications Universal 6.0 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Comedy Comics 34 Fall 1946 Timely Comics Universal 8.5 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Hedy De Vine Comics 27 6/48 Marvel Comics Davis Crippen (""D"" Copy) Universal 6.5

Jughead's Jokes 1 8/67 Archie Publications Curator Universal 9.6 WHITE

Little Archie 1 1956 Archie Publications Universal 4.5 CREAM TO OFF-WHITE

Millie the Model 36 9/52 Atlas Comics Davis Crippen (""D"" Copy) Universal 7.0 CREAM TO OFF-WHITE

Mitzi Comics 1 1948 Timely Comics Universal 7.5 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Nellie the Nurse 6 4/47 Marvel Comics Universal 8.0 CREAM TO OFF-WHITE

Pep Comics 66 3/48 MLJ Magazines Universal 6.5 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Pep Comics 153 3/62 Archie Publications Bethlehem Universal 7.0 LIGHT TAN TO OFF-WHITE

Tip Top Comics 187 7-8/54 United Features Syndicate Universal 5.0 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Wendy Parker 1 7/53 Atlas Comics Universal 7.0 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Young Love 1 2-3/49 Prize Publications Universal 6.5 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

 

[Comicdey]

Can you pm me my list of grades ::

[143ksk]

Can you pm me my list of grades ::

 

[JWKyle]

 

That was alot of fun thank you for running the contest.

[comicdonna]

Great contest Steve! I see I haven't lost my touch. Started out in first place and ended nearly last.

[Comicdey]

I went down in flames, but great to see the results. Thanks for running the contest.

[Sal]

Sub-Mariner Comics 14 Fall 1944 Timely Comics Universal 5.0 CREAM TO OFF-WHITE

Archie Comics 2 Spring 1943 MLJ Magazines Universal 2.5 CREAM TO OFF-WHITE

Dizzy Dames 1 9-10/52 American Comics Group Edgar Church (Mile High) Universal 8.5 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE 8.5

Archie Comics 36 1-2/49 MLJ Magazines Universal 7.0 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Archie 167 9/66 Archie Publications Universal 9.4 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Archie's Girls Betty and Veronica 40 1/59 Archie Publications Universal 7.5 OFF-WHITE

Archie's Pal Jughead 103 12/63 Archie Publications Universal 9.6 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Chamber of Chills 19 9/53 Harvey Publications Universal 6.0 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Comedy Comics 34 Fall 1946 Timely Comics Universal 8.5 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Hedy De Vine Comics 27 6/48 Marvel Comics Davis Crippen (""D"" Copy) Universal 6.5

Jughead's Jokes 1 8/67 Archie Publications Curator Universal 9.6 WHITE

Little Archie 1 1956 Archie Publications Universal 4.5 CREAM TO OFF-WHITE

Millie the Model 36 9/52 Atlas Comics Davis Crippen (""D"" Copy) Universal 7.0 CREAM TO OFF-WHITE

Mitzi Comics 1 1948 Timely Comics Universal 7.5 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Nellie the Nurse 6 4/47 Marvel Comics Universal 8.0 CREAM TO OFF-WHITE

Pep Comics 66 3/48 MLJ Magazines Universal 6.5 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Pep Comics 153 3/62 Archie Publications Bethlehem Universal 7.0 LIGHT TAN TO OFF-WHITE

Tip Top Comics 187 7-8/54 United Features Syndicate Universal 5.0 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Wendy Parker 1 7/53 Atlas Comics Universal 7.0 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

Young Love 1 2-3/49 Prize Publications Universal 6.5 OFF-WHITE TO WHITE

 

 

wow, I suck at grading from a scan.

 

[universal soldier]

That was alot of fun thank you for running the contest.

 

+1

[asteroid-comix]

 

I couldn't even win last place

 

Great contest though!

[thirdgreenham]

How about the prizes?

[trmoore54]

Great contest Steve and very nice assessment of your own books! A great batch of books!

 

I fell down hard early in the contest but was very pleased to claw my way back to a respectable 31 points...

 

THX AGAIN Steve! Lotta fun!

[byosti]

surprised won this, only have a few golden age books in my collection....sorry took me few days to respond. was away during the time this was posted. but thanks all for the congrats. perhaps i may even put it in my sig now