Action Comics #1 CGC grade comparison in pictures

[Bat-Man]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Just for the fun of it.

 

 

 

 

[And for the record I (of course ) do NOT own any of these books, just a dreamer here drooling.

 

All images are borrowed from auction websites. ]

[mikephoen]

Cool!

 

 

[Flash105]

The 2.5 and 5.0 have very nice eye appeal.

[Mr. 10%]

 

The corner torn 2.5 looks like a gift compared to the others, when judged from the FC

[Mio]

True true. That 2.5 is rough. I wonder what it would get on re-sub...

[Primetime]

nice Alex! thanks for "putting together" that run of A1s I'd take the 1.8 or 2.0 over that POFC 2.5 copy.

[mt1000]

Very cool Alex, that 4.0 looks very nice

[cyberjad]

Very cool post. Thanks for sharing

[Bat-Man]

nice Alex! thanks for "putting together" that run of A1s I'd take the 1.8 or 2.0 over that POFC 2.5 copy.

 

This is the only way I will ever put together all these Actions 1's - in pics in a thread.

 

I completely agree Ben, the 1.8 or 2.0 over that 2.5 dreadful copy any day.

 

 

I think that 2.0 is worlds more desirable than that 2.5 "POFC copy" ( ) as you say.

[Bat-Man]

Thanks everyone!

 

It's just fun to view them all (all I could find scans of quickly anyway) in one place in ascending order.

[comicnoir]

Really great!

 

That 2.5 looks like a dog's breakfast.

[TSwift25]

One day...one day....

[showcase22gr1959]

Very cool to see all those A1s. Maybe you can have a batch of A13's. Now, if only the A1 2.5 has a chunk like that missing in the back instead of the front.

[tth2]

Very cool idea, thanks for putting these together. (thumbs u I just hope it doesn`t give people any ideas in a certain SA thread devoted to Showcase 22.

 

The 5.5 copy you posted now resides in a 6.5 slab.

[Mac Man]

True true. That 2.5 is rough. I wonder what it would get on re-sub...

 

I'd imagine the owner of that book would never resubmit it... though I suspect CGC would probably like to have resubmitted so they could apply a correct grade to the label.

[Mutie Fan]

True true. That 2.5 is rough. I wonder what it would get on re-sub...

 

I'd imagine the owner of that book would never resubmit it... though I suspect CGC would probably like to have resubmitted so they could apply a correct grade to the label.

 

I've heard it said they wish they could get that one back.

[innocuous]

Thanks for putting this together. It's a fun view.

 

 

I just hope it doesn`t give people any ideas in a certain SA thread devoted to Showcase 22.

I think this is already done in someone's signature.

[BOOT]

Very cool and informative post! Thanks very much for putting that all together!

[Kirk Kenobi]

That was amazing. Thanks for posting these.

[tth2]

Thanks for putting this together. It's a fun view.

 

 

I just hope it doesn`t give people any ideas in a certain SA thread devoted to Showcase 22.

I think this is already done in someone's signature.

Thankfully I`ve got signatures turned off.