5th Annual March Madness CGC Grading Tournament- Seeding Round

[porky]

13-4 for me... I think

[toro]

I did fairly well except for that Hulk 118, did anyone get that right? I overgraded that thing as well as Kung Foo! But I only lost points on the Hulk.

 

This is what I sent in for grades.

 

Conan the King #47 W 9.4

Defenders #34 OW-W 8.0

Fantastic Four #55 9.0

Fantastic Four #61 8.5

Incredible Hulk #118 Cr-OW 9.0 ( not even close )

Jungle Action #6 W 9.4

Master of Kung Fu #18 Cr-OW 9.6 (went back and fort on 9.4 and 9.6, evidently need new reading glasses and new monitor)

 

Strange Tales #147 W 9.4

Thor #132 OW-W 9.0

Tales of Suspense #70 OW-W 7.0

[drewincanada]

yup both you and I had to play in and we both loss

 

It was triple overtime game. Link.

 

Ah yes, it all comes back to me now. There were six of us competing for 2 play-in spots.

 

I lost my play-in in overtime. You lost your play-in in triple overtime. Crazy.

[DiceX]

I think I'm 13/6.

 

 

[Columbia Comics]

I did fairly well except for that Hulk 118, did anyone get that right?

 

I hit the bullseye on the Hulk 118

[toro]

On the back bottom corner on the 118, was there paper loss there? Or was it just banged up?

[etanick]

I think I'm 13/6.

 

 

same as my score...that should get us in the middle tier

[Nostalgic Attic]

On the back bottom corner on the 118, was there paper loss there? Or was it just banged up?

 

Little piece missing.

[Columbia Comics]

On the back bottom corner on the 118, was there paper loss there? Or was it just banged up?

 

Little piece missing.

 

That's what I thought as well...

 

Let's get the seeding done and get this rolling...should be fun!

[toro]

On the back bottom corner on the 118, was there paper loss there? Or was it just banged up?

 

Little piece missing.

 

That's what I couldn't tell. I probably would have still missed it, but not by as much.

[Nostalgic Attic]

I will have the seedings and bracket posted late tonight PST. There are some hard decisions to make with a few teams having over 30 wins!

 

Past rankings will have to play into the convoluted, irrational seeding formula no doubt.

[JazzMan]

I will have the seedings and bracket posted late tonight PST. There are some hard decisions to make with a few teams having over 30 wins!

 

Past rankings will have to play into the convoluted, irrational seeding formula no doubt.

 

30!

[B3AST]

Maybe I should just concede now.

 

I'm with you there

Said I was out of grading practice and boy was I ever way off on almost all those books

[spideyfan76]

My grading skills are poor as ever. Also my typing skills seem to be horrible too as I was trying to decide between 9.4 and 9.6 on the Conan I went with the obvious and typed 8.0

[SolitaireOne]

... I went with the obvious and typed 8.0

 

[trmoore54]

I was either spot on (4) or not -1 or -2 off (4)...

 

I think if I calculated correctly...19-6

[oakman29]

4 bullseyes. I think I'm 19-8

[Jeffreykli]

Looks like 12-8 for me. Hopefully good enough to avoid the play-in game.

[Aces]

I did fairly well except for that Hulk 118, did anyone get that right? I overgraded that thing as well as Kung Foo! But I only lost points on the Hulk.

 

This is what I sent in for grades.

 

Conan the King #47 W 9.4

Defenders #34 OW-W 8.0

Fantastic Four #55 9.0

Fantastic Four #61 8.5

Incredible Hulk #118 Cr-OW 9.0 ( not even close )

Jungle Action #6 W 9.4

Master of Kung Fu #18 Cr-OW 9.6 (went back and fort on 9.4 and 9.6, evidently need new reading glasses and new monitor)

 

Strange Tales #147 W 9.4

Thor #132 OW-W 9.0

Tales of Suspense #70 OW-W 7.0

 

Those were my two losses too... Hulk 118 and the Kung Fu book.

[oakman29]

I graded the Hulk 118 a 9.0 as well.