Whats a GA book everyone wants, that means noting to you? 6 6

[I am not Glenda]

Note: I got this idea off another site I am on and we had  blast with it, so I thought it would be interesting to see what the GA books would be.

Golden age only:

My piclk would be any of ASH can GA , they just do not interest me at all.

[eccomic]

I know I am going to be tarred and feathered...LOL

Golden Age GGA..too much hype... I predict the only desirable GGA in two years time will be Baker and Feldstein (Junior) .....the current LB Cole GGA hype is certainly cyclical and will trend down soon enough, along with Georgie, Millie and the gang (Atlas) .

Edited January 31, 2018 by eccomic

[MrBedrock]

Amazing Man 5

[Ltpink2002]

Archie 50

[Timely]

Whiz #2. Any Four Color comic.

[fishbone]

No interest whatsoever in any  Romance

 

.....wait, that doesn't sound right for some reason......

Edited January 31, 2018 by fishbone

[Scrooge]

1 hour ago, Timely said:

Any Four Color comic

These are not comics everyone wants ...

[originalisbest]

10 minutes ago, Scrooge said:

These are not comics everyone wants ...

Ouch!

I am a PCH nut, yet, Eerie #1 really doesn't do it for me. I can appreciate others appreciate it, though. That'd be my perfect example of a book I'd put up for sale, and use the proceeds to grab PCH more to my liking.

 

[X_Phile]

1 hour ago, fishbone said:

No interest whatsoever in any  Romance

 

.....wait, that doesn't sound right for some reason......

+1

[rainmaker]

may get roasted for this one... schomburg marvel mystery.  too busy.  i can appreciate them but dont think i will ever own one.  

[KirbyJack]

Most PCH is a miss for me, as are most GGA covers, but my strong first thought here is Suspense 3.

[KirbyJack]

42 minutes ago, rainmaker said:

may get roasted for this one... schomburg marvel mystery.  too busy.  i can appreciate them but dont think i will ever own one.  

I like them, but I'm down to just a single example in my collection. I get what you're saying.

[paul747]

Any of the non- super hero cover only golden age books.  Zero attachment and really cant believe some of the prices and wonder who will pick up the torch on those books in 10-20 years.

[aardvark88]

Suspense Comics #3 (Continental), sorry: early # Planet Comics as the interior art and story is not memorable compared to later issues with Murphy Anderson art. Although it is hard not to buy a tasty Planet Comic with  Zolnerowich cover.

[october]

Zero interest in owning (for anything near market value):

Whiz 2

Feldstein GGA 

Anything Dan DeCarlo

A lot of Schomburg stuff (most of it looks the same to me)

 

Question for the GGA guys: why do Dan DeCarlo Millie issues bring like 20x what DeCarlo Irma books bring and 20x what Stan Goldberg stuff brings? It all looks the same to me and seems random. What is the deal?

Edited February 1, 2018 by october

[domuhnator]

Schomburg Marvel Mysterys, Never owned one and I probably never will. 

Also Pep comics 34. Don't get me wrong I like the cover and would 100% buy one. But it commands a silly price IMO. 

[sacentaur]

Ashcans (any). 

[ender]

Any Sensation Comics. I think Wonder Woman is a great character but that art is just off putting to me 

[atomised]

I'm not a big fan of some of the early Superman books, I feel they lack some of the interesting cover compositions found in Action Comics.  Superman #2 in particular doesn't excite me much at all.  That said, I respect these books so I could never say they mean nothing to me.

[telerites]

Batman books with his Dork Boy sidekick.  Tec' 38 ruined Bats forevermore.   I mean just think how many more baddies Bats could nab if he didn't waste his time rescuing Blunder Boy.

 

 

Bats gets a migraine when he realizes what a mistake he made...