2022 "THIS SCORE NEEDS FIXIN" REQUESTS"
3 3

82 posts in this topic

Hi Brian

Could you take a look at a couple more Silver Age books which I inadvertently omitted from my previous post.

Many thanks.

Title # Significance of Book Current Registry Points for Universal 9.4 grade Most recent GPA for Universal 9.4 grade ($)
         
Tales to Astonish 90 First Silver Age Appearance of Byrrah; First appearance of Abomination 270 3232
Tales to Astonish 91 First Abomination cover 270 800
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi there, 

Set: Something is Killing the Children (Complete)

Book: Something is Killing the Children #16 Scott's Collectables Edition B

Could you readjust these scores to make them commensurate with the other books in this set?  They are currently all 1 point across the board.

Thanks.

Edited by Violent-Delights
Misspelled word.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

Could you take a look at the scores in the Jim Lee Cover Set? There are several issues that I think are scored less than they should be

- Batman #608 City of Burbank edition is the rarest of all variants for the Batman Hush run. It is not for retail sale and only available as a promotional giveaway through the City of Burbank instagram page. So far only 20 copies have been given away and 5 of those have been graded. The issues that have come for sale have fetched a couple K...

- Wonder Woman # 1 (2016) convention/2nd printing - this is the gold foil cover that was printed in error for NYCC. Only a limited amount were printed with the error. There is even a more a rarer sub-variant of the book which has a gold cover and silver back.

- There were several 1:1000 variants re-mastered variants that Marvel released of Jim's work. These are all highly sought in high grades:

Captain America  #700 remastered Sketch variant

X-Men: Blue #1

X-Men: Gold #1

Astonishing X-Men #1

 

Thanks!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello!  First time posting here.  Hope you can help!

Set: Famous Monsters of Filmland
Slot: Do-It-Yourself Monster Make-Up Handbook nn

A 9.4 sold for $1500 in the last year.  This book, from 1965, has been sought after for as long as I remember.  A Universal 9.4, highest graded, only grades out at 150 points.  Can this be adjusted?


Thanks

Alec

Edited by Elroy Jetson
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Can you please adjust the score for 

Skybound X #1 Big Clutch variant Cert # 3889983021

It has a print run of 80 copies with only 27 having been graded by CGC, and those sent to friends and family. There has only been 3 publicly auctioned/sold - 2 CGC 9.8s and 1 raw, with the most recent going for $686 +tax and shipping.

Thanks

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not sue about this, me and @Poka both have a 9.4 Batman Beyond #1. His is worth 300, mine says 405, while the 1st ranked set has a 9.6, and it has 675 points. Attached are pics of the rankings, and what the Batman Beyond #1 points system say, 675 and 405 are nowhere to be found.

Might want to check values of $$ too :) 

 

image.thumb.png.6b1cdf0307864d06c9cce484eff409dd.png

image.thumb.png.e9639177835f5e04e7e4bc6454b81d18.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello,

Although I recognize that entire sets is not what you are looking to fix, I would appreciate your consideration in raising the point value of the Marc Spector: Moon Knight series from its current numbers to something in the realm of the new Moon Knight books. It does not have to be on an individual basis, but the books current values (other than the Platt Covers) are well below the current 2021 Moon Knight run.

Also for some reason my Black Panther book has a score of Zero.

image.png.307e41e934cb657f3dd7db5a79029a12.png

I recognize it is not a key, but it should be worth something hm

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Brian,

Can you please take a look at the scores for the following books? If points are based loosely off of what books sell for then these should be adjusted:

Amazing Fantasy 15 CGC 7.5 - Currently has a score of 91667. If you look at GPA as well as auction results the book has recently been selling in the $300k range. Even if you disclude the 2022 sales the books has been selling around $150k since 2017 so the score should be adjusted to at a minimum 150000 points.

Fantastic Four 1 CGC 8.0 - Currently has a score of 58800. GPA for lower grades (7.5) is currently selling for $168k, (6.5) $88k, and higher grades (9.2) $1.5mil. So the 8.0 is very underscored currently. It should be at least tripled at a minimum.

Incredible Hulk 1 CGC 8.5 - Currently has a score of 159524. GPA for this grade is currently $245k and lower grades (8.0) are $188k and (7.5) $106k. The 8.5 should be adjusted to at least 200000 points at a minimum.

Showcase 4 CGC 8.5 - Currently has a score of 36180.  Prices are a little tricky because it doesn't come up often at high grade. The last public GPA sale was in 2017 for $150k. However a 4.5 sold in 2022 for almost $33k which is basically what the current points are for the 8.5. So this book is very underscored. It should be at least 150000 points maybe more.

Showcase 22 CGC 8.5 - Currently has a score of  8375. This may be the most underscored book in my request. CGC 5.5 currently sell for $8855 which is about the current points for the 8.5. The last recorded GPA sale was in 2020 at 8.5 for $36k. A 9.0 sold in 2019 for $66k which is already 3 years old and would go for more in the current market. So the 8.5 should be at least 50000 points, maybe more as it is scarce and sitting at the top of its census numbers.

X-Men 1 CGC 9.2 - Currently has a score of 112500.  The last 3 sales on GPA in grade are $250k, $276k and $305k. Lower grades are selling for higher than the current points. This book should be at least 250000 points.

Fantastic Four 5 CGC 8.0 - Currently has a score of 9870. Last GPA sale in grade from 2021 is $24k. Lower grades (7.0) have sold in 2022 for $37k (6.0) $28k. So this book is underscored. It should be at least 45000 points or more.

Fantastic Four 52 CGC 9.0 - Currently has a score of 3700. In grade since 2021 sales have been 410k-$13k. This book should be at least 10000 points.

Journey Into Mystery 83 CGC 8.0 - Currently has a score of 30450. Last sale in grade was $69k in 2021. In lower grades (7.0) in 2022 for $41k and (6.5) for $29k. So this book is underscored. It should be at least 50000 points or more.

Journey Into Mystery 85 CGC 9.2 - Currently has a score of 10500. There hasn't been a sale in grade since 2019 but a 7.5 sold recently for $15k. 9.2 sits towards the top of the census on a tough book. I would think this book should have a score of at least 35000 points if not more.

Strange Tales 110 CGC 9.0 - Currently has a score of 16000. In grade last sale was $41k with a lower grade of 8.5 selling for $26k. This book should be at least 35000 points or more.

Tales of Suspense 39 CGC 8.0 - Currently has a score of 18900. Last sale in grade was 2021 for $89k. Lower grades (7.0) have sold this year for $50k (6.5) for $33k. This book should be at least 65000 points or more.

Superman 2 CGC 8.0 - Currently has a score of 8400. The last sale in grade was 2019 for $42.5k. Lower grades (7.5) for $37k and (6.0) for $15k. This book is one of the tougher Superman books form the Golden Age and is way under scored. It should be at least 45000 points or higher.

More Fun Comics 101 CGC 6.5 - Currently has a score of 2100. Sales for lower grades in 2021 (6.0) $4080, (5.5) $3360 and (5.0) $4635. This book should be at least 5000 points.

Justice League of America 1 CGC 8.0 - Currently has a score of 5880. This book has been selling for $12k since 2015. This should have a score of at least 12000.

Please let me know if you have any questions.  I would imagine these score changes would affect all other grades too. Thanks for your consideration and for taking a look!

Andy

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/25/2022 at 10:00 PM, Andy L said:

Hi Brian,

Can you please take a look at the scores for the following books? If points are based loosely off of what books sell for then these should be adjusted:

Amazing Fantasy 15 CGC 7.5 - Currently has a score of 91667. If you look at GPA as well as auction results the book has recently been selling in the $300k range. Even if you disclude the 2022 sales the books has been selling around $150k since 2017 so the score should be adjusted to at a minimum 150000 points.

Fantastic Four 1 CGC 8.0 - Currently has a score of 58800. GPA for lower grades (7.5) is currently selling for $168k, (6.5) $88k, and higher grades (9.2) $1.5mil. So the 8.0 is very underscored currently. It should be at least tripled at a minimum.

Incredible Hulk 1 CGC 8.5 - Currently has a score of 159524. GPA for this grade is currently $245k and lower grades (8.0) are $188k and (7.5) $106k. The 8.5 should be adjusted to at least 200000 points at a minimum.

Showcase 4 CGC 8.5 - Currently has a score of 36180.  Prices are a little tricky because it doesn't come up often at high grade. The last public GPA sale was in 2017 for $150k. However a 4.5 sold in 2022 for almost $33k which is basically what the current points are for the 8.5. So this book is very underscored. It should be at least 150000 points maybe more.

Showcase 22 CGC 8.5 - Currently has a score of  8375. This may be the most underscored book in my request. CGC 5.5 currently sell for $8855 which is about the current points for the 8.5. The last recorded GPA sale was in 2020 at 8.5 for $36k. A 9.0 sold in 2019 for $66k which is already 3 years old and would go for more in the current market. So the 8.5 should be at least 50000 points, maybe more as it is scarce and sitting at the top of its census numbers.

X-Men 1 CGC 9.2 - Currently has a score of 112500.  The last 3 sales on GPA in grade are $250k, $276k and $305k. Lower grades are selling for higher than the current points. This book should be at least 250000 points.

Fantastic Four 5 CGC 8.0 - Currently has a score of 9870. Last GPA sale in grade from 2021 is $24k. Lower grades (7.0) have sold in 2022 for $37k (6.0) $28k. So this book is underscored. It should be at least 45000 points or more.

Fantastic Four 52 CGC 9.0 - Currently has a score of 3700. In grade since 2021 sales have been 410k-$13k. This book should be at least 10000 points.

Journey Into Mystery 83 CGC 8.0 - Currently has a score of 30450. Last sale in grade was $69k in 2021. In lower grades (7.0) in 2022 for $41k and (6.5) for $29k. So this book is underscored. It should be at least 50000 points or more.

Journey Into Mystery 85 CGC 9.2 - Currently has a score of 10500. There hasn't been a sale in grade since 2019 but a 7.5 sold recently for $15k. 9.2 sits towards the top of the census on a tough book. I would think this book should have a score of at least 35000 points if not more.

Strange Tales 110 CGC 9.0 - Currently has a score of 16000. In grade last sale was $41k with a lower grade of 8.5 selling for $26k. This book should be at least 35000 points or more.

Tales of Suspense 39 CGC 8.0 - Currently has a score of 18900. Last sale in grade was 2021 for $89k. Lower grades (7.0) have sold this year for $50k (6.5) for $33k. This book should be at least 65000 points or more.

Superman 2 CGC 8.0 - Currently has a score of 8400. The last sale in grade was 2019 for $42.5k. Lower grades (7.5) for $37k and (6.0) for $15k. This book is one of the tougher Superman books form the Golden Age and is way under scored. It should be at least 45000 points or higher.

More Fun Comics 101 CGC 6.5 - Currently has a score of 2100. Sales for lower grades in 2021 (6.0) $4080, (5.5) $3360 and (5.0) $4635. This book should be at least 5000 points.

Justice League of America 1 CGC 8.0 - Currently has a score of 5880. This book has been selling for $12k since 2015. This should have a score of at least 12000.

Please let me know if you have any questions.  I would imagine these score changes would affect all other grades too. Thanks for your consideration and for taking a look!

Andy

 

 

those are some KILLER books you have in your collection :golfclap:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Batman 222, 232, 234 may need to be revisited, I think #227 too. Some concrete higher multiple sales in lower grades. I know that you usually go by 9.8 and trickle down, but I thought there might not have been any 9.8's or at least no 9.8 sales of late. idk beyond that lol 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would appreciate a look at Amazing Spider-Man #3. Comiclink just sold a 9.0 for 35000 (on 5/31)

and Heritage just sold a 9.0 for 44400 (on 6/2). Current registry pointage for a 9.0 is 9800.

Thank You

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Can you please take a look at the Walking Dead Deluxe set for a point increase of the following books All these books were either limited for purchase or could only be purchased from the Comics Vault Live Show graded: 

Walking Dead Deluxe #1 Black Foil Edition: Cert# 3737915088

Walking Dead Deluxe #1 Finch Sketch Cover Cert# 2615347011

Walking Dead Deluxe #1 Gold Foil Edition Cert# 3813799006

Walking Dead Deluxe #1 Red Foil Edition Cert #            

Walking Dead Deluxe #1 Second Printing Sketch Cover Cert# 3874945001

Walking Dead Deluxe #1 Second Printing Gold Foil Edition Cert# 3805545155

Walking Dead Deluxe #1 Second Printing Red Foil Edition Cert# 3805436206

Walking Dead Deluxe #2 Second Printing Gold Foil Edition Cert# 3812903061

Walking Dead Deluxe #2 Second Printing Red Foil Edition Cert# 3812901134

Walking Dead Deluxe #2 Second Printing Sketch Cover Cert# 3874945002

Walking Dead Deluxe #3 Second Printing Gold Foil Edition Cert# 3848932087

Walking Dead Deluxe #3 Second Printing Red Foil Edition Cert# 3848928070

Walking Dead Deluxe #3 Second Printing Sketch Cover Cert# 3874945003

Walking Dead Deluxe #4 Second Printing Gold Foil Edition Cert# 3861863160

Walking Dead Deluxe #4 Second Printing Red Foil Edition Cert# 3861877011

Walking Dead Deluxe #4 Second Printing Sketch Cover Cert# 3874945004

Walking Dead Deluxe #5 Second Printing Gold Foil Edition Cert# 3883476018

Walking Dead Deluxe #5 Second Printing Red Foil Edition Cert# 3884181176

Walking Dead Deluxe #5 Second Printing Sketch Cover Cert# 3874945005

Walking Dead Deluxe #6 Second Printing Gold Foil Edition Cert# 3904924178

Walking Dead Deluxe #6 Second Printing Red Foil Edition Cert# 3905640034

Walking Dead Deluxe #6 Second Printing Sketch Cover Cert# 3874945006

Walking Dead Deluxe #7 Finch Sketch Cover Cert# 3774883075

Walking Dead Deluxe #7 Second Printing Gold Foil Edition Cert# 3903859047

Walking Dead Deluxe #7 Second Printing Red Foil Edition Cert# 3903869071

Walking Dead Deluxe #7 Second Printing Sketch Cover Cert#                                            

Walking Dead Deluxe #8 Second Printing Gold Foil Edition Cert# 3923851180

Walking Dead Deluxe #8 Second Printing Red Foil Edition Cert# 3923823159

Walking Dead Deluxe #8 Second Printing Sketch Cover Cert# 3917092002

Walking Dead Deluxe #9 Second Printing Gold Foil Edition Cert# 3949257383

Walking Dead Deluxe #9 Second Printing Red Foil Edition Cert# 3949257159

Walking Dead Deluxe #9 Second Printing Sketch Cover Cert# 3917092001

Walking Dead Deluxe #10 Second Printing Gold Foil Edition Cert# 3990975099

Walking Dead Deluxe #10 Second Printing Red Foil Edition Cert# 3990979120

Walking Dead Deluxe #10 Second Printing Sketch Cover Cert# 3917092005

Walking Dead Deluxe #11 Second Printing Gold Foil Edition Cert# 3990980097

Walking Dead Deluxe #11 Second Printing Red Foil Edition Cert# 3990981087

Walking Dead Deluxe #11 Second Printing Sketch Cover Cert# 3917092004

Walking Dead Deluxe #12 Second Printing Gold Foil Edition Cert# 

Walking Dead Deluxe #12 Second Printing Red Foil Edition Cert# 

Walking Dead Deluxe #12 Second Printing Sketch Cover Cert# 3927657004

Walking Dead Deluxe #13 Gold Foil Edition Cert#                                                                   

Walking Dead Deluxe #19 Darboe Variant Cover Cert# 3887814153

Walking Dead Deluxe #27 Comics Vault Live Edition A Cer # 3984519080

Walking Dead Deluxe #27 Comics Vault Live Edition B Cert# 3984519238

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Request edited on 6 June - this was fixed by the Registry Processing System.  Book was added and scores created!  Thank you!
 

Hello, this book doesn’t appear to have scores and I cannot add it to a set (although it DOES have a slot). Appreciate the help!

Cert # 3698928002

1DA09F3E-B2B3-4635-A74C-A3E479C8B193.thumb.jpeg.3729ca79e8f7a523f153fc4d8932bc5e.jpeg

Edited by Iconic1s
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Teenage mutant ninja turtles#51 idw set.

Needs adjustment.

1st human appearance of fifth turtle jennika or however it reads on the cgc label, so important.

9.6 sells for $200+ 9.8 for even more.

9.6 points are only 15 points. :(

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 6/6/2022 at 2:00 PM, ADAMANTIUM said:

Teenage mutant ninja turtles#51 idw set.

Needs adjustment.

1st human appearance of fifth turtle jennika or however it reads on the cgc label, so important.

9.6 sells for $200+ 9.8 for even more.

9.6 points are only 15 points. :(

 

 

Cert number for slab of #51

2069083022

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
3 3