2023 CGC Grading Contest Season 2 Fall Edition #8 Round 1 14 14

[Stefan_W]

Yikes, 10 - one of my worst rounds ever

[CGC Mike]

Here's a link to round 2.  I will finish recording grades from this round later tonight.

 

[southern cross]

Scored a lucky 7 🙄

[jcjames]

6pts, no bulls, off by one grade on all but one book (Perfect Crime), no complaints. 

Supersnipe #9   6.0 +1

Super Mystery V5 #3   4.0 +1

Horrific #7   3.0 +1

Perfect Crime #28   2.5 +2

War Action #2   8.0 +1

[bighairjer]

I’ll take 7 points for category “you are a crappy grader” please.

[universal soldier]

5 pts. with a bull, I'll take it. Should have listened to my gut on the Super Mystery and the War Action and it would have been a great round.

 

Supersnipe #9 - 5.5 +2

Super Mystery V5 #3 - 4.0 +1

Horrific #7 - 3.0 +1

Perfect Crime #28 - 3.5 

War Action #2 8.0 +1

Edited October 24, 2023 by universal soldier

[g-man]

2 🎯 

still a score of 10

[grendelbo]

2 bulleyes. Score of 5. 

[paqart]

My worst round ever. I got a 10. If I had gone with my first impression, would have gotten 5 points.

[WilliamLunt]

1 bullseye, Score of 5. My Delta was -5 soooooooooo I should probably just lighten up my grading.

[ChrispyC66]

• Supersnipe #9 - 4.5  (4)
• Super Mystery V5 #3 - 4.0  (1)
• Horrific #7 - 2.5  🎯
• Perfect Crime #28 - 3.5. 🎯
• War Action #2 - 7.5  🎯

I convinced myself there was a 2”+ spine tear on the bottom of Supersnipe. Score of 5. Could be worse, I suppose.

[Yorick]

On 10/23/2023 at 5:10 PM, universal soldier said:

Supersnipe #9 - 5.5

That's my grade too.  Couldn't see it any higher than a 6.0.  Oof.  2 points 

[zzutak]

I really, really, really wanted to assign the Horrific #7 a 2.5, but I kept flashing back to this masking-tape defaced monstrosity from Contest #7.  One book becomes my nemesis in two separate contests!   

[WilliamLunt]

I really want to see how the board did on the Supersnipe. 5.5 seemed like the top end.

[JollyComics]

On 10/23/2023 at 7:34 PM, zzutak said:

I really, really, really wanted to assign the Horrific #7 a 2.5, but I kept flashing back to this masking-tape defaced monstrosity from Contest #7.  One book becomes my nemesis in two separate contests!   

You are not alone. I have same problem with Horrific last content and this content.  I pray that will be the last one.

[Axelrod]

Undergraded every book! 

8 for me.

[JollyComics]

1st round in all contents is my average 6.5 points.

This round is 3 points with three bullseyes (tied best personal record - both points and bullseyes).  I think I am behind two best scores.

• Supersnipe #9 - 6.5  🎯
• Super Mystery V5 #3 - 4.5  🎯
• Horrific #7 - 3.5  2 points
• Perfect Crime #28 - 4.0 1 point
• War Action #2 - 7.5  🎯

Hopefully, no more surprised grades in next three rounds except HORRIFIC books!!!

Edited October 24, 2023 by JollyComics

[brumil190]

5 points Good round for me.  1 bull,  2 points on the Supersnipe and 1 point each on the other three books.. I couldn't get myself to grade higher than 5.5 on the Supersnipe even though I suspected the cgc grade would be higher.

[comicginger1789]

6 for me

Like many I undergraded the Supersnipe. I had 5.5 and convinced myself to go 5.0

I was also a grade lower on the Super Mystery. The rest, two bulls and one a grade under. I’m still in the “there a hole in hell zone” so I’ll take it

[Cushing Fan]

Supersnipe #9 - 7.0

Super Mystery V5 #3-5.5

Horrific #7-4.0

Perfect Crime #28-5.0

War Action #2-7.5

 

One bullseye and close on two books but that Horrific and Perfect Crime really threw me for a loop.