No other PREACHER pages in my collection I'm not sure I understand the question :make point:
My first OA purchase was a PREACHER page and it's been downhill ever since.
As for a side by side comparison of the last two title pages that have been auctioned? The issue 10 page is the better of the two, in my opinion, for the reasons I stated above. I should have went stronger on the page, but backed off at the last minute. I'll be interested to see this surface on CAF.
It's a hypothetical question. IF you had no PREACHER examples, and you were given a choice of these two, which would you pick? I'm not asking which one you think is "better" necessarily, but which one would you rather have?
If you picked the second page, you are going to be in a tiny minority (of one:P). Anyway, I think your bids on each page reveal your heart's true desire.
For me, the second page is the better of the two
I like the "art" of it. The tone and mood of the page is more appealing to me than the humor of the other page.
My CAF is a testament (when I have everything active) to the fact that I don't mind being the only fan of certain artists or series
My bids are more an indicator of available funds at the time than my hearts desire