Wrong printing discovered in Returned PGX Graded Book- Do I have legal options?

[Timmay]

.

 

I have about 30% of my slabbed books as PGX. The other 70% is of course, CGC'd. If I decide to sell any of my PGX slabbed books, I will most likely just de-slab them, using the pGX grade as a guide, and sell them raw.

 

 

I would consider having them graded by CGC. I tried PGX once and was dissapointed in the grades received.

 

On the flip side, I've cracked a few PGX slabs (purchased already slabbed) and the majority have come back in a higher grade from CGC.

 

 

The only downside to cracking a PGX book would be the possibility of missed resto, wrong print, etc.

[Bosco685]

The only downside to cracking a PGX book would be the possibility of missed resto, wrong print, etc.

Always make sure you are ready when doing so. Some guy on eBay is selling this $200 "How to crack open a PGX case" kit. Sounds like a decent investment.

 

 

 

[Timmay]

The only downside to cracking a PGX book would be the possibility of missed resto, wrong print, etc.

Always make sure you are ready when doing so. Some guy on eBay is selling this $200 "How to crack open a PGX case" kit. Sounds like a decent investment.

 

 

 

you're missing the pic of the KY jelly

[codfish]

This is a case of an insufficiently_thoughtful_person scamming an insufficiently_thoughtful_person ... no matter whose side you take.

 

What I don't get is even though this guy had problems I believe he admits submitting books to PGX up to late 2007 ... if I read his "conclusion" post over at CPG right.

[Jimmy Linguini]

So now that PGX claims they paid out the OP and (claim they) were scammed by him but still ended up paying him out,

 

What is the general conscience of this being a scam or not?

[SquareChaos]

I couldn't get past the first 10 pages of this thread... there are a lot of in this forum. Sure, maybe it turned out the guy was trying to pull something, but damn... harsh.

[steveinthecity]

A week or so back a forum member(goldeneye), claimed that MagicDan had admitted as much to the whole thing being a fraud on the CPG forum in order to burn PGX. No link was provided. My impression after viewing the video initially was the entire thing was staged.

[Buzzetta]

I've seen better acting at a 6th grade Christmas play.

[Jimmy Linguini]

There has been some recent revelations on a different comic forum in regards to PGX.

 

(i.e. Facebook pages of the graders being posted and Dan of PGX claiming Ryan Elliott has noting to do with PGX, except that he is facebook friends with all of the graders + comments on their posts)

 

I would be really surprised if the TMNT #1 PGX scam turned out to be a fallacy,

[Lazyboy]

PGX got scammed. Everybody feels very sorry for them.

 

(One of those statements may be substantially less accurate than the other.)