March Madness Grading Tournament- Seeding Round

[trmoore54]

There will be play-in games for the teams ranked 61-68- one play-in game for each region. The matchups are as follows:

 

61. slseals 8- 5 vs. 68. xsmanx 5- 7

62. 1koko 8 -5 vs. 67. Boozad 6- 8

63. marvelcollector 7- 5 vs. 66. cookie1963 7- 6

64. Byosti 7 -5 vs. 65. Flatrock02 7 -6

 

Good Luck to everyone.

 

Get yer grades in so we can move on.

 

 

YEAH!

[slseals]

Guesses submitted...

[TheDanimal]

I thought that was some sort of moldy foxing?

 

I still like it. You can sell it to me after this round I actually NEED it!

[slseals]

So that's... what... two of us out of the 8 so far?

[cookie1963]

So that's... what... two of us out of the 8 so far?

 

I dont know i submitted my grades 5 hours ago.

and I will stick with my grades i already submitted

 

just waiting

[slseals]

Yep, from what I can tell 1 + 1 = 2

 

Even if you can't tell it from my grading in the first round...

[toro]

Two people had the GS Cap at 8.5, I had it at 9.2 and someone else listed 9.4. Did anyone actual grade that one a 9.6? Isn't that a small color breaking crease in the bottom right hand corner? I never get those GS and King Sized books right.

 

[Point Five]

Two people had the GS Cap at 8.5, I had it at 9.2...

+1...

 

 

[TheDanimal]

That cap was a 9.6??? I think I had it at 8.5. That little color breaking crease, while tiny, shouldn't be on a 9.6 right?

[slseals]

I had the Cap at 8.5 also because the top of the spine looked blunted to me. Looks that way from both sides of the scans, that with the apparent crease...

[zuckuss2003]

I had the GS Cap at 9.0

[drewincanada]

Two people had the GS Cap at 8.5, I had it at 9.2...

+1...

 

 

9.2 here, too.

[ARK]

I was one of two that had the Cap GS at 8.5. I saw the small corner crease and the blunted edge and had to guess under a 9.0, but CGC treats the GS's pretty kind.

[jessebrook1]

I was the other person who said 8.5. The color breaking crease and Upper left hand corner is what made me say 8.5

[Comicdey]

Two people had the GS Cap at 8.5, I had it at 9.2...

+1...

 

 

9.2 here, too.

+1 @9.2

[BlowUpTheMoon]

I had the GS Cap at 9.4

 

[divad]

Two people had the GS Cap at 8.5, I had it at 9.2...

+1...

 

 

9.2 here, too.

+1 @9.2

 

I had it at a 9.2 also . . . MUST be an otherwise PERFECT book

[DiceX]

I had the GS at 8.5. Totally stunned at that grade with the corner crease.

It was like throwing up an airball at that one.

 

 

[Shark]

I had the GS Cap at 9.4

 

+1

[BlowUpTheMoon]

I had the GS at 8.5. Totally stunned at that grade with the corner crease.

It was like throwing up an airball at that one.

 

 

I thought it might be SCS with a scanner glare.