GRADING CONTEST : ROUND 5

[davidking623]

Oh shoot just checked the census and there are no 6.5 copies. Well that just shows you need to check the census in this game

 

Grade the Book! Not the Census!

 

Davidking623

[Aman619]

I did that too, but stuck with my 6.5. I cant believe it got less than that, but it appears so from the "unhappy" icons we all got. I got my fingers crossed that Nikos is facking with us, but theyve been crossed for days now and I think will be permanentlycramped for naught.

[Fan4Fan]

Oh shoot just checked the census and there are no 6.5 copies. Well that just shows you need to check the census in this game

 

Grade the Book! Not the Census!

 

Davidking623

 

Census-grader hater!

[Norrin_Radd]

Oh shoot just checked the census and there are no 6.5 copies. Well that just shows you need to check the census in this game

 

Grade the Book! Not the Census!

 

Davidking623

 

But at the same time, ignore the census at your peril.

 

It's a double standard I tells ya!

[davidking623]

I did that too, but stuck with my 6.5. I cant believe it got less than that, but it appears so from the "unhappy" icons we all got. I got my fingers crossed that Nikos is facking with us, but theyve been crossed for days now and I think will be permanentlycramped for naught.

 

Might have to superglue them apart so to start getting them back to there proper place to be used again!

 

Davidking623

[nik]

Damn it, I had to retype all this because I checked my last minute PMS and lost the whole post, damn it Greggy

 

The following guessed 8.0 and receive 0 Points

 

1 TheBrain

2 Higghawker

 

The following guessed 7.5 and receive 0 Points

 

1 Blutobc

2 Lantern

3 PedigreMan

 

The following guessed 7.0 and receive 0 Points

 

1 SterlingComics

2 Uclapeterg

3 Jimm94

 

The following guessed 6.5 and receive 0 Points

 

1 NorrinRadd

2 DrBanner

3 Bobpfef

4 Hobgoblin

5 Burntboy

6 Eric123

7 BassGman

8 Valiantman

9 Aman619

 

The following guessed 6.0 and receive 1 Point

 

1 DNAgent

2 MithrilMan

3 FFB

4 Rjpb

5 Namisgr

6 Postal

7 Zipper68

 

The following guessed 5.5 and receive 2 Points

 

1 Jeffreykli

2 SilverSurfer

3 Aces

4 DiceX

5 Jayman

6 Warlord

7 Zonker

8 Inconceivable

9 Fan4Fan

10 AlexH

11 CW

12 Nefaria

 

The following NAILED THE GRADE

 

1 OctoberFire

2 Divadrabnud

3 143ksk

4 Scrooge

5 RustyStaple

6 MrWoogieman

7 Verygoodplus

8 Ultimatevenom

9 ThanosOftitan

10 Toro

11 Comicsupply

12 TheGreatest

13 Imagemask

14 Arty

15 Belladonna

16 Davidking623

17 Kingofrulers

 

The following guessed 4.5 and receive 2 Points

 

1 R1970d

2 OldGuy

3 Hobbes

4 TheBeyonder

5 Arexcrooke

6 Deathlok

7 Darthdiesel

8 Brockley

9 Eddly

10 Supremo

11 Ze-Man

12 Wasonff

 

The following guessed 4.0 and receive 1 Point

 

1 Bullseye

2 Redhook

3 ArAich

 

The following guessed 3.5 and receive 0 Points

 

1 XsmanX

2 Whet

3 Flink

 

The following guessed 3.0 and receive 0 Points

 

1 Trevorlsmith

 

The following did not submit a grade

 

1 Awe4One

2 Sal

3 Casey1870

[blutobc]

I think I'll blame my guess this round on "inner ear disease"...I heard that it's going around.

[toro]

All Right 3 in a row,,,the allmost comeback kid!!!

[s-man]

Sensed I was undergrading it a bit..

[davidking623]

Sorry to hear that Nikos! Darn computers dont they know do what we want not what they want!

 

Davidking623

[Silver Surfer]

I knew it but I went with the safe bet as there was only 1 6.0 and no 6.5's. The yellowed chip on the right edge and the comments "general wear" screamed mid grade copy all the way.

[divad]

The following NAILED THE GRADE

 

1 OctoberFire

2 Divadrabnud

3 143ksk

4 Scrooge

5 RustyStaple

6 MrWoogieman

7 Verygoodplus

8 Ultimatevenom

9 ThanosOftitan

10 Toro

11 Comicsupply

12 TheGreatest

13 Imagemask

14 Arty

15 Belladonna

16 Davidking623

17 Kingofrulers

 

[divad]

I knew it but I went with the safe bet as there was only 1 6.0 and no 6.5's. The yellowed chip on the right edge and the comments "general wear" screamed mid grade copy all the way.

 

The BC tells the whole story

[Silver Surfer]

The following guessed 7.0 and receive 0 Points

 

1 SterlingComics

2 Uclapeterg

3 Jimm94

 

Boys what's going on here?

[ArAich]

I can't believe this got a 5.0 !!! ...No offense Nikos but I have a 4.5 that just blows this book away...Gawd...this is either the Nikos factor in affect or I was stricken with the ArAich factor when I had my book graded...

[PedigreeMan]

 

That book's undergraded. I'd sue CGC.

 

[divad]

 

That book's undergraded. I'd sue CGC.

 

 

[Jayman]

The following NAILED THE GRADE

 

1 OctoberFire

2 Divadrabnud

3 143ksk

4 Scrooge

5 RustyStaple

6 MrWoogieman

7 Verygoodplus

8 Ultimatevenom

9 ThanosOftitan

10 Toro

11 Comicsupply

12 TheGreatest

13 Imagemask

14 Arty

15 Belladonna

16 Davidking623

17 Kingofrulers

 

 

Congrats on all who nailed the grade!

 

Even you divad...

[divad]

The following guessed 8.0 and receive 0 Points

 

1 TheBrain

2 Higghawker

 

The following guessed 7.5 and receive 0 Points

 

1 Blutobc

2 Lantern

3 PedigreMan

 

The following guessed 7.0 and receive 0 Points

 

1 SterlingComics

2 Uclapeterg

3 Jimm94

 

The following guessed 6.5 and receive 0 Points

 

1 NorrinRadd

2 DrBanner

3 Bobpfef

4 Hobgoblin

5 Burntboy

6 Eric123

7 BassGman

8 Valiantman

9 Aman619

 

The following guessed 3.5 and receive 0 Points

 

1 XsmanX

2 Whet

3 Flink

 

The following guessed 3.0 and receive 0 Points

 

1 Trevorlsmith

 

 

[blutobc]

3.0 to 8.0 now thats some range in grading.

 

Even though I tanked this round...this is the kind of book I don't mind seeing in the contest. Low and Mid grade books are so much harder to figure out than those 9.0 and up books. I leaned toward going as low as 6.5 which wouldn't have gotten me any points either....but I applied the "supposed" golden age curve rule and bumped it even higher.

 

On to the Avengers double cover book.