FF 67 or Thor 165?

[JollyComics]

Which book do you think it deserves the title and will get more attentions?

 

Fantastic Four #67 Origin and 1st appearance of Him (Warlock) in cameo OR

 

Thor #165 1st full appearance of Him (Warlock)?

[Illustrious]

Thor #165

[JollyComics]

So far, the score is...

 

Thor 165 1

FF 67 0

[Spidey-fan73]

To put it simply

 

FF67 = Hulk 180

Thor165 = Hulk 181

 

Foom doesn't count, bub.

[Chip Cataldo]

Marvel Premiere #1

 

Peace,

 

Chip

[JollyComics]

Marvel Premiere #1

 

Peace,

 

Chip

 

Cuz you have it?

[JollyComics]

To put it simply

 

FF67 = Hulk 180

Thor165 = Hulk 181

 

Foom doesn't count, bub.

 

I noticed that.

[Gotham Kid]

To put it simply

 

FF67 = Hulk 180

Thor165 = Hulk 181

 

 

yup. Thor 165.

 

 

[JollyComics]

The score is...

 

Thor 165 3

FF 67 0

[zuulioso]

FF66

[JollyComics]

 

Me but thanks. Let's poll!

[crnbrd]

Peter in Portugal, I only vote in polls that have a "crack" option.

[Gotham Kid]

Peter in Portugal, I only vote in polls that have a "crack" option.

 

[kav]

Dang I bought that thor a year ago for $5.

Wish I bought more

[ChicksCosmiComics]

Having hg copies of both hard to pick. I'd say thor 165 ends up being the big money book

 

[kav]

ebay says it all

[JollyComics]

The poll shows Thor edges FF by 8 votes.

 

Let's see if the post will have 100 votes. Which book has more edges.

[ChicksCosmiComics]

The other thing Thor 165 has going for it is a slick black cover.

[Dr. Balls]

No love for Marvel Premiere #1?

 

FF67 and Thor 165 being the first appearance of Warlock is like saying Marvel Super Heroes 13 is the first appearance of Ms. Marvel.

 

The only reason people are totally focused on these two books is because OSPG have mis-attributed his appearance for decades. They refer to those issues as "1st appearance of Warlock (HIM)". Which is incorrect, especially if you consider he's not called 'Warlock' until the 70s, nor does he have the personality or power set that he is known for until that time.

 

But, hey - why sweat the details?

[Dr. Balls]

The other thing Thor 165 has going for it is a slick black cover.

 

True, also FF67 is a really tough white cover. In all the issues I've bought over the years - I only had one really nice white cover that didn't have dirt, off-color or foxing issues.