-
When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
William-James88
-
Posts
4,693 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Forums
CGC Journals
Gallery
Events
Store
Posts posted by William-James88
-
-
On 12/1/2023 at 7:51 PM, Tom789 said:
I recently got a book back from CGC, which graded it an 8.5. The grader notes don't mention that the back cover is detached from the bottom staple. I even included a sticky note mentioning it because I was hoping they would use extra handling care. Should the notes have mentioned the detachment?
I don't think this defect brings it below an 8.5, though, so I'm not worried about that. But please correct me if I'm wrong!
I'm a bit confused, why would the back cover be detached but not the front cover? And was anything detached when initially sent?
Also, for that book, any detachment would lower it much more. The 8.5 does not account for any detachment, it is for the creasing and spine stress.
And can you post a picture of it being detached because I don't see that in the images provided by CGC.
And one last question, this one just out of pure curiosity, but why did you send this specific book in?
-
-
@The Sledder just wanted to give a shout out in case you still need extra help
-
On 11/24/2023 at 3:13 PM, stormflora said:
Sadly, as a newbie collector, I have no idea what comics are considered valuable. Even if I dropped by some yard sale that had tons of vintage comics for sale, I wouldn't know which ones were valuable or not for resale. Perhaps someone could provide me with some summarized pointers for what would be must-buys if I ever encountered them.
The price guide is your friend. It will highlight which vintage comic is worth more than others by giving it its own line with its own higher pricepoints.
But if you are a collector, then I'd suggest just collecting instead of thinking of reselling because when it comes to reselling, the grade becomes a major factor too. As you collect, you'll learn a lot.
And buy what you love, because even if you are simply collecting odds are that what you like is what someone else likes too. And thus the value is preserved through the demand based on your tastes.
In the end, you'll be surrounded by books you love and while they may or may not gain value, they will still be wanted by at least one person, you.
-
Honestly, as long as demand is higher than supply, a key book will hold value.
Warehouse finds will affect books which demand is solely based on speculation or perceived rarity.
Hence why chasing a trend or wanting something just because it's "valuable" may not work out.
-
On 11/25/2023 at 7:25 PM, Kramerica said:
I want Greggy back and posting regularly.
as long as he's in the Christmas raffle
-
On 11/25/2023 at 6:08 PM, Dr. Balls said:
Thank you. Just doing my part to make Hot Girls and Comic Books not mutually exclusive.
Any Aspen reader knows that is far from the case .
-
On 11/25/2023 at 1:36 PM, 1950's war comics said:
it's been a ghost town around here without kav's great posts ... kav knew a lot about comics and comic book art !
i am glad Vintage has picked up some of the slack in trying to make these boards great again
I've been gone a bit, what happened to Kav?
-
On 11/25/2023 at 2:05 PM, Chip Cataldo said:
...and yet, most of the people that post here, don't.
They aren't as comprehensive as they want people to think.
Yeah, but that you doesn't matter since they dont cater to us. They are more interested in looking like a comic book Mecca destination. Images of their warehouse get posted every now and again on the various Comic book facebook groups I'm in with people posting " wish I worked there" or "will be sure to visit" or whatever, and I don't see that for other shops, at least not on the same level.
Every hobby has this type of store which is more about becoming an attraction in itself.
-
On 11/23/2023 at 3:44 PM, BA773 said:
LOL
Is it someone who buy at these guys?
Every modern drek are priced for 20 dollar or more. Every keys are priced for at least 3x the value...
I want to understand the concept. Is it some rich people who buy to this place to be proud of spending a lot of money? This is make no sense
This is a pretty old topic at this point because them being overpriced is part of their gimmick, and they dont care. They don't want to be competitive in terms of pricing, they want to be the place where you are sure to find what you are looking for.
-
I will participate.
Mix of trades/hardcovers pictured below. Will ship to US and Canada and will include Canadian chocolate bars.
- ashsaytr, The Sledder and ADAMANTIUM
-
3
-
Just talking for myself but the mountain of mainstream media content has really burnt me out. Itself combined with its impact on the hobby by bringing in more speculation and huge magnitude in price swings for comics have made everything more overwhelming and have lessened my fun. At least for now.
Plus I've been priced out for the vintage books I collected. So I don't really have much to talk about.
-
Even though practically no one watch this year's Shazam film, golden age comics for that character are still climbing. You used to be able to buy lots of fawcetts below guide 5 years ago, but those days are long. Or at least from what I've seen and follow.
-
When it comes to comics, not usually.
-
On 4/28/2023 at 11:34 PM, jimbo_7071 said:
It won't be strong compared to other books, but compared to prices on the same books before, yes. You could usually buy them for below guide, like 20-30% below guide, aside from keys (which is where the title of this thread comes from). But now lots are going for above guide. Like this recent auction, where the lot went for 25% above guide.
Same thing with this one random comic:
And this lot went for 50% over guide for FR-GD copies
-
Man, so much can change in 2-3 years. The market for these got hot and prices went up. How do we rename threads? I'd change this to Fawcett Comics Appreciation thread.
I didn't buy much at all since the last time I poked my head out, I got most of the ones I wanted and the ones I don't have are too expensive to my liking. BUT I did find this on ebay recently for 70$. Obviously, not in great shape, but it's complete and the colours are vibrant and I didn't have to pay hundreds just to have one in my collection.
-
On 11/17/2022 at 7:35 AM, Bosco685 said:
I know. 'Anti-Woke' - whatever that implies.
More like Woke Anda!
https://giphy.com/gifs/bQCWmEgKHasZG
- Bosco685 and TupennyConan
-
2
-
There's no big movie coming out for another month. So I'm pretty sure Wakanda Forever will get to at least 900 mil like Dotore Strano.
-
On 11/14/2022 at 10:28 PM, thegiftedone45 said:
Now I don't get to see T"Challa any longer so it sucks.....
You'll definitely get to see some T"Challa going forward.
-
My thoughts on Wakanda Forever. It was good but very long , with not enough points of excitement that would make me go back to it often. Honestly, I could have done without all the white people, it could have simply been about 2 dueling nations without getting the rest of the world involved, which in turn needed more cutting back to and a longer run time. LOVED Namor. He's purposefully larger than life in the comics to a point of parody almost, which makes him a harder character to adapt. And I think they pulled a monumental feat with this adaptation. He was charismatic but still very much an antagonist, which feels very classic silver age but in the MCU. It was a perfect adaptation of the character within the MCU and showed what he could specifically bring to it that no one else could. Also, and this is purely subjective, I was si damn glad that they showed off Angela Basset and Lupita Nyong'o's curves in this films and did not shy away from their incredible beauty, something I felt the first film did. I know there's been some talk that this film may have too much "estrogen" but, true to form, Namor provides all the testosterone a film would ever need. I felt the balance there worked well. Oh another issue I has was with the CGI for Ironheart's final amor. It was way too smooth, giving it almost a 2D feel, which may have been intentional to go with the anime vibes of the suit. But it didn't look like she was in the suit in the shots where she removes the faceplate.
Im the end the film is long but there's goid stuff. Loved the women and loved the man, Imperious Rex!
- aardvark88 and Unca Ben
-
1
-
1
-
On 7/14/2022 at 11:28 PM, Sqeggs said:
A couple more dubious ones, but I love 'em all!
There's also one where he meets a penguin that I could do without.
-
On 7/13/2022 at 8:08 PM, Robot Man said:
A fun one hit my mailbox today. And,I consider what I paid pretty cheap.
Congrats, that's one that I myself have been looking for.
-
On 7/8/2022 at 2:49 PM, mlansdown said:
Well saying they "can be" means it's not a rule. That's the whole point. They are golden age gems that can go for thousands, but they can also go for less than $100. Like these 2 that I just picked up. Bought them from Harley at a Canadian con so I paid the sticker price but in Canadian dollars so they came out to $50 USD and $60 USD respectively (no tax, no shipping of course). Pretty cheap for GA. One's a Raboy and the other is a Communist Menace cover.
- adamstrange, telerites, Sqeggs and 1 other
-
4
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
Here is my haul from the Montreal Comiccon, all the Fawcett books are from Harley Yee. Also got sketches from Kevin Eastman and Dan Parent.
They aren't as comprehensive as they want people to think.
Detachment not mentioned in grading notes
in Comic Book Grading and Restoration Issues
Posted
Ah, thanks I get it now. Ok, technically that does not count as a detached cover defect, so while I'm not sure how I would personally grade it, the grade you got is not out of the realm of possibility. And yeah, they don't write every defect in the notes. So I'd say your cleared and all is OK.
Still curious about why you picked this specific book to get graded, does it have a special meaning for you?