• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

1000 comics in 2015 book club

433 posts in this topic

I put the books I thought were better on top. The ones not quite as good on the bottom. I'll be rating the books on a scale of 1 to 5 ice cold PBR Talls.

 

Doktor Sleepless 1-13 by Warren Ellis 5 out of 5

The Exterminators 1-30 by Simon Oliver and Tony Moore and Darick Robertson and a few other artists maybe. I can't recommend this book enough....4.0 to 5.0 PBR Talls

 

Fell 1-9 by Ellis and Templesmith short 16 page detective stories...4.0 to 5.0 PBR Talls. My favorite issue was #3. You must try a few issues.

Hawkeye 1-12, annual 1, Hawkeye 13-21 by Matt Fraction overall 4.5 PBR Talls

Nextwave 1-12 by Warren Ellis and Stuart Immonen...4.5 PBR Talls

Destroyer 1-5 by Kirkman and Cory Walker 4.5 PBR Talls

 

Invincible by Kirkman duh 68-70, and Invincible Returns #1 one shot

Invincible 71-117.........4.0 to 5.0 PBR Talls

Brit by Kirkman 1-3 prestige format...4.0 PBR Talls

Brit 1-12 regular series by Bruce Brown...3.5 PBR Talls

Atom Eve 1, 2 and Atom Eve And Rex Splode 1-3 by Cereno...4.5 to 5.0 PBRs

Guarding The Globe 1st series 1-2 by Kirkman and Cereno...3.5 PBR Talls

 

Daredevil by Mark Waid 1-7, Amazing Spider-Man 677 by Waid

Daredevil 8-10, 10.1 by Waid, Avenging Spider-Man 6 by Rucka and Waid

Punisher 10 by Rucka, Daredevil 11-30 by Waid

Indestructible Hulk 9-10 by Waid, Daredevil 31-36 by Waid-DD 30 was boring with Silver Surfer but there was 2 cool parts that made it worth it and the 2 Hulk issues were boring. Everything else 4.5 PBR Talls.

Daredevil 0.1, 1.5, 1-5 by Waid

 

Four Eyes 1-4 by Joe Kelly 4.5 talls out of 5

Django Unchained 1-7...4.5 talls out of 5

East Of West 1-10 by Hickman 4.0 PBR Talls

The Manhattan Projects 1-5 by Jonathan Hickman...3.5 to 4.0 PBR Talls

Jupiter's Legacy 1-5 by Mark Millar...4.0 PBR Talls

Hellblazer 134-139 Haunted by Ellis and Higgins 4.0 PBR Talls

Trees 1-8 by Warren Ellis..Started very slow but once it gets going it's good. 3.0 to 4.0 PBR Talls

Hellblazer Shoot by Ellis...3.5 PBR Talls

The Courtyard 1-2 goes into Neonomicon 1-4 by Alan Moore

The Originals by Dave Gibbons 3.5 to 4.0

Secret 1-3 by Hickman 3.5 PBR Talls

 

Hardcore 1 by Kirkman 3.5 out of 5

Murderer 1 by Kirkman 3.5 out of 5

They're Not Like Us 2-3 by Eric Stephenson...3.5 PBR Talls

Lady Killer 1-2 by Joelle Jones and Jamie Rich...3.5 PBR Talls

Elektra 1 by Blackman and Del Mundo... 3.0 PBR Talls cool art

Batman Noel by Lee Bermejo...3.0 PBR Talls

 

total 274

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Batgirl (New 52) 13-16

Batman 478, 588-590

Batman (New 52) 13, 14, 17

Batman & Robin (New 52) 15-17

Batman Beyond 1-6

Batman: Gotham City Secret Files 1

Buffy The Vampire Slayer: Tales Of The Slayers GN

Buffy The Vampire Slayer: Tales Of The Slayers - Broken Bottle Of Djinn

Buffy The Vampire Slayer: Tales Of The Vampires 1-5

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Season Eight - Tales Of The Vampires "The Thrill" one-shot

Catwoman (New 52) 13, 14

City Of Others 1-4

Dark Horse Presents 34

Deathstroke (2011) 1-8

Detective Comics 787, 871-881

Detective Comics (new 52) 15-17

Doom Patrol (vol. 2) 19-50

Essential Dr. Strange Volume 1

Fables 94-140

Fables: 1000 Nights Of Snowfall

Fantastic Four 1-10, 485, 526

Filthy Rich (A "graphic mystery")

Flex Mentallo 1-4

Gotham Central 12-15, 19-25, 28-31, 33-40 (stupid old TPBs!)

Guardians Of The Galaxy 0.1, 1-3,

GotG: Tomorrow's Avengers 1

Harlan Ellison's Phoenix Without Ashes 1-4

The Invisibles vol.1 1-25

The Invisibles vol.2 1-22

The Invisibles vol.3 12-1 (yes, counting downward!)

JLA (1997) 1-4

JLA/Planetary GN

Manhattan Projects 1-15

Mind MGMT 0-6

New Mutants 65, 66

Nightwing (New 52) 14-16

Punisher (1985 LS) 1-5

Red Hood (New 52) 13-16

Savage Sword Of Conan 1-10

Savage Tales Of Conan 1-5

Savage Wolverine 12-17

Scalped 35-60 (!!!)

Spawn Fan Edition 1

Strangers In Paradise (vol. 3) 77-90

Suicide Squad (New 52) 14, 15

Superman/Aliens 1-3

Teen Titans (new 52) 14-16

Thanos: The Infinity Revelation (OGN)

The Ultimates 1-6

Uncanny X-Men 311, 313, 397

Vertigo Winter's Edge 1

Wolverine: Origins 28-30

Wonder Woman 160-161

The X-Files 13-19

X-Men Legacy 217-218

X-Men: No More Humans (OGN)

X-Men: Original Sin

X-Treme X-Men 24, 31-39

 

 

425 issues so far...

 

 

 

-slym

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Updated entry

 

DC:(20)

Superman: 28

Injustice Gods Among Us Year Two: 1-6

Justice League New 52: 1-6, 7-12

JLA Earth 2 (OGN)

 

Marvel: (3)

Star Wars (Current) 1-2

Darth Vader: 1

 

Image: (24)

Saga: 1-18

Manifest Destiny: 6-12

 

Total: 47

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thor: God of Thunder 1-23

Ms Marvel (2006-2010) 1-50

Runaways (2003) 1-18

Runaways (2005-2008) 1-30

Runaways (2008-2009) 1-14

Batgirl 1-37

Civil War: Young Avengers & Runaways 1-4

Avengers Origins 1-5

5 Ronin 1-5

Captain America (2011-2012) 1-19

Immortal Iron Fist (2006-2009) 1-27

Immortal Weapons (2009) 1-5

Captain America (2011) 1-19

100th Anniversary Special: Spider-Man 1

100th Anniversary Special: Fantastic Four 1

Amazing Spider-Man (1999-2013) 600-700

The Wicked + The Divine 1-6

The Multiversity 1-5

The New 52: Future's End 20-31

Civil War: the Complete Event (97 comics)

Fall of the Hulks: including tie-ins (16 comics)

House of M: including tie-ins (49 comics)

Messiah Complex: including tie-ins (19 comics)

Messiah War: including tie-ins (7 comics)

Second Coming: including tie-ins (19 comics)

Testament 1-22

Ultimate Spider-Man 1-133

Ultimate Fantastic Four 1-57

Ultimate X-men 1-97

Fairest 1-26

 

925

 

 

-most of the comics were read on Marvel Unlimited.

 

:o:o:o

 

That is amazing! You are averaging over 21 comics per day. I can read novels all day long but reading that many comics in the same time period would make my brain hurt. lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Update

TMNT Ultimate Collection 1-12, 14,15,17,19-21 Raphael, Michelangelo, Donatello and Leonardo one shot

The Walking Dead 1-48

The Avengers (1st series) 1-4

Saga 1-24

Y the last man 1-10

Fables 1-27

Runaways (vol 1) 1-18

Rat queens 1-5

Total:158

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Batman 608

Ultimate Fantastic Four 1-11

Deathstroke (Vol. 2) 2-3

Chew 16-20

Nailbiter 10

Guardians of the Galaxy (2013) 23

Rocket Raccoon 7

Legendary Star Lord 8

Ms. Marvel 11

 

Added: 24

2015 Total: 224

 

The Amory Wars Second Stage Turbine Blade 1-5

The Bag On Line Adventures: The Second Stage Turbine Blade 1-2

 

Really got into Coheed and Cambria lately and wanted to check out Claudio's work. My girlfriend got me the Amory Wars Ultimate Edition for Valentines Day so I started reading it. The Bag On Line Adventures are the two original comics that were re-adapted into the first two issues of the Amory Wars. I kind of prefer the original. It's a good Sci-Fi read. I'll definitely be picking up In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3 Ultimate Edition.

 

 

Added: 7

2015 Total: 231

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Les Tuniques Bleues

T. 48 - Arabesque - count: 2

T. 49 - Mariage a Fort Bow - count: 2

T. 50 - La Traque - count 2

T. 51 - Stark sous toutes les coutures - count: 2

 

Cellule Poison

T. 4 - Dans les serres de l'aigle - count: 4

T. 5 - Comptines - count: 4

 

Le maitre de Benson Gate

T. 3 - Le sang noir - count: 3

T. 4 - Quintana Roo - count: 3

 

La Liste 66

T. 3 - Kansas - count: 2

T. 4 - Oklahoma / Texas - count: 2

T. 5 - ... Californie - count: 2

 

Les demons d'Alexia

T. 4 - Le syndrome de Salem - count: 2

 

Orbital

T.4 - Ravages - count: 2

T. 5 - Justice - count: 2

 

Sherman

T. 5 - Les ruines, Berlin - count: 2

T. 6 - Le pardon, Jeannie - count: 2

 

Thorgal

T. 8 - Alinoe - count: 2

T. 9 - Les archers - count: 2

T. 10 - Le Pays Qa - count: 2

T. 11 - Les yeux de Tanatloc - count: 2

T. 12 - La cite du dieu perdu - count: 2

 

Le vol du corbeau T. 2 - count: 2

 

Les chroniques de la lune noire

T. 5 - La danse ecarlate - count: 2

 

Blacksad

T. 5 - Amarillo - count: 2

 

Picsou: count: 4

Le dernier du Clan Mc Picsou

Le roi du Mississippi

Buck Picsou des Badlands

L'aventurier de la Colline de Cuivre

 

Astro City: 17 - 18

Avenger A.I. - # 6 - 12 - count: 7

Batman: 35, 36, 37

Batgirl: 35

Bodies: 4 - 6

Cable and X-Force - # 16 - 19 - count: 4

Conan the Avenger: 7 - 9

Daredevil:

Vol. 3 - # 33 - 36 - count: 4

Vol. 4 - # 1 - 5 - count: 4

Ex-Con: 2, 3, 4

Fables: 145 - 147

The Fade Out: 3 - 4

Fairest: 32 - 33

Fantastic Four - # 14 - 16 - count: 3

Hinterkind: 13

Justice Inc. 3 - 5 - count: 3

Lazarus: 12 - 13

Little Nemo returns to Slumberland: 2

The Massive: 28 - 30

Rachel Rising: 29 - 30

Saga: 24

Secret Avengers - # 11 - 16 - count: 6

Starlight: 6

Stumptown - The case of the king of clubs: 2 - 4 - count: 3

Superior Spider-Man Annual # 1 - count: 1

Superior Spider-Man Team-Up # 6 - 12 - count: 7

The Unwritten - Apocalypse: 10 - 11

Veil: 5

Wild's End: 2 - 4

Winterworld: 3 - 5

Wytches: 1, 2, 3

 

 

Rat Queens - T.1 - Sass & Sorcery - # 1 - 5 - count: 5

 

Captain Midnight - T.1 - On the run - # 0 - 3 - count: 4

 

Coffin Hill - T. 1 - Forest of the night - # 1 - 7 - count: 7

 

Locke & Key: Keys to the Kingdom - # 1 - 6 - count: 6

 

Chew:

Flambé: 16 to 20 - count: 5

 

Prophet

Remission: 21 - 26 - count: 6

Brothers: 27 - 31 and 33 - count: 6

 

The Manhattan Projects:

T. 2 - # 6 - 10 - count: 5

T. 3 - # 11 - 15 - count: 5

 

Revival:

T.1 - You're among friends - # 1 - 5 - count: 5

T.2 - Live like you mean it - # 6 - 11 - count: 6

T.3 - A faraway place - # 12 - 17 - count: 6

 

Andre the Giant - Life & Legend - count: 10

 

The Harlem Hellfighters - count: 10

 

Louis L'Amour - Law of the Desert Born - count: 6

 

Avengers: 4, 5

Tomb of Dracula: 6, 7

 

Polly and her Pals, vol. 1 - 1913 - 1927 - count: 7

 

 

Update:

 

American Vampire - Second Cycle # 6 - Yeah

Astro City: 19 - Still superb

Batman: 38

Bodies: 7 - Arrghh - never delivered on the premise. Glad # 8 closes this mini

Conan the Avenger: 10 - Previous issue was much better. Art is getting more and more rushed.

Ex-Con: 5 - Same here, art was distracting by the end. OK concept.

Fables: 148

Hinterkind: 14 - 15 - Still really digging this one.

Justice Inc. 6 - Strongest issue of the run. Uslan is not a good writer but I like his choice of topics.

Lazarus: 14 - :cloud9:

Little Nemo: Return to Slumberland: 3 - Just finished Locke & Key, Rodrigez is also killing it on this series

Saga: 25

Stumptown - The case of the king of clubs: 5 - Not the strongest mini in this series of minis

The Unwritten - Apocalypse: 12 - Appropriate finale to this series. Will have to read it over. Loved The Books of Magic as it was released years ago but couldn't hack through it on a re-read. Would think this holds up better. Next up: big TPB 1 of Lucifer.

Southern Bastards: 7 - Some twisted people in the South. Panels with the coach revealing why no interest from college teams was gut-wrenching

Star Wars: 1 - 2 - OK. Not a big Star Wars fan and certainly no huge fan of Cassaday's art so this is mildly entertaining

Tooth & Claw: 1 - 3 - THIS is a book with much better art. In this one to stay

Wild's End: 5 - Still entertaining. Glad I picked it up though there is really little to no story at all.

Winterworld: 6 - 7 - Tomas Giorello (of the King Conan minis) can make snow & ice lush!!

Wytches: 4 - Really not digging this one from Snyder, I have them on pre-order but it's not clicking for me.

 

Locke & Key: Clockworks - count: 6

Locke & Key: Alpha & Omega - count: 7 - All around splendid. Would love to own a one volume hard cover of this. Is there one?

 

The Sixth Gun:

T1 - Cold dead fingers: 1 - 6

T2 - Crossroads: 7 - 11

T3 - Bound: 12 - 17 - Yes, supernatural done well. I will continue to hunt this one down

 

Thorgal - T 13 - Entre terre et lumiere - Enjoyable as always

 

Doug Wildey's Rio - The Complete Saga - count: 12 - Couldn't do an update without a Western in the list. This itched me in the right spots. Was really happily surprised by the stories from Wildey. Knew he wanted to prove a point with the art but he revealed himself as a decent writer at the same time.

 

Below is my attempts to "dry up" my library in Marvel U. Fairly uneven material but some pleasant surprises, caught myself enjoying Nova for example & Superior Spider-Man; Wolverine & the X-Men by Aaron should never have ended!

 

Thunderbolts: 18 - 29 - count: 12

Uncanny X-Men: 14 - 24 - count: 11

X-Men: 7 - 17 - count: 11

All-new X-Men: 19 - 30 - count: 12

Avengers Assemble: 21 - 25 - count: 5

Daredevil: 6

Infinity: Heist: 3 - 4

Infinity: The Hunt: 4

Nova: 10 - 19 - count: 10

Superior Spider-Man: 22 - 32 - count: 13

What if: # 1

Uncanny Avengers: 14 - 22 - count: 9

Uncanny X-Force: 14 - 17 - count: 4

Wolverine & the X-Men: 38 - 42 and Annual # 1 - count: 6

Spider-Man # 700.1 - 700.5 - count: 5

Fearless Defenders # 12

Amazing X-Men: 1 - 10 - count: 10

Avengers Annual # 1

 

Total: 251 + 185 = 436

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hinterkind: 14 - 15 - Still really digging this one

 

I liked the 1st tpb, athough the art was kinda a turn off. If the story is still good I'll probably stay with it.

 

Also, glad you liked the Sixth Gun. It's a great story; too bad it turned off a lot of people when the TV pilot didn't get picked up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Amazing Spider-Man #332-333, #346-347, #361-363, #374-375 Annual #21

Avengers #59-60, #127, #167-168, #170-177, #181-187 and Annual #16

Contest Of Champions #1-3

Dardevil: The Man Without Fear #1-5

Fantastic Four #150, Annual #3

Incredible Hulk #319

Thor Annual #6

West Coast Avengers Annual #2

X-Men #30 (90's series)

Amazing Spider-Man #4-7 (current series)

The Walking Dead #134-135

Wolverine #20-32 (2004 Millar/Romita Jr.)

Amazing Spider-Man #8-13 (current series)

The Walking Dead #136 --- it's getting good.....

Marvel Fanfare #18

Captain America #302-317

Kick-*spoon* #1-8

Miles Morales Ultimate Spider-Man #5-9

Hit-Girl #1-5

 

 

 

 

UPDATE:

Iron Man #258-265

Kick- 2 #1-7

 

TOTAL : 124

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Osborn: Evil Incarcerated #1-5

Kingpin #1-7

Spider-Man: Lifeline #1-3

Spider-Man: Quality of Life #1-4

Spider-Man: Doctor Octopus Year One #1-5

Spider-Man: Death & Destiny #1-3

Spider-Man: Final Adventure #1-4

Spider-Man: Lost Years #0-3

Spider-Man: Redemption #1-4

Spider-Man: With Great Power... #1-5

 

Haven't ready much Spidey in the past 10 years, this was enough to hold me over for another 10. Doc Ock Year One was my favorite; the Lost Years/Redemption made my head hurt and JRJR's art in the former was truly awful.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Latest Update:

 

Back Issues:

Identity Crisis 1-4

Adventures of Superman: 611, 627-630

Superman the Man of Steel: 133

Action Comics v1: 798

Superman v2: 189

Stormwatch: 40

Superman/Batman: 1-9

JSA: 60

 

New52:

Action Comics: 38-39

Batman Eternal 39-41

Detective Comics: 37

Superman: 37-38

Green Lantern: 32-37, FE, Godhead

Green Lantern Corps: 32-36, FE

New Guardians: 32-36, FE

Sinestro: 3-7, FE

Red Lanterns: 32-36, An1, FE

Supergirl: 32-33, 37-38

Batman: 6-10

Batman and Robin: 6-9

Batwoman: 6-9

Red Hood and the Outlaws: 37-38

Star Spangled War Stories ft. GI Zombie: 4

Grayson: 6, An1

Flash: 37-38

Secret Six: 1

Futures End: 32-39

Worlds End: 9-12

Earth 2: 29

Deathstroke: 3

Justice League United: 7-8

Justice League: 38

Gotham by Midnight: 2

Justice League 3000: 13 (great book)

Multiversity: The Just

 

Marvel:

Star Wars: 1 (good start)

 

Other:

Wayward: 1-5

Mercenary Sea: 8

D&D Legends of Baldur's Gate: 2-3

Conan/Red Sonja: 1

Conan the Avenger: 7

Lady Mechanika: 0

 

New: 5

2015 Total: 114

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hinterkind: 14 - 15 - Still really digging this one

 

I liked the 1st tpb, athough the art was kinda a turn off. If the story is still good I'll probably stay with it.

 

DC released their May 2015 solicits and Hinterkind # 18 is listed as last issue so no real reason to stick with it.

 

DC has successfully managed to leave me with very very few titles in my pull list: Batman and American Vampire IIRC, two Snyder books. The rest bears no interest to me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So, started in on the first trade of the Fairest series from Bill Willingham, and thought the start was rather abrupt, but whatever. Then, as I got about 5 whole pages (10 pages) in, I noticed someone ripped out an entire page. I kept going, and did OK enough with comprehension, until just a few more pages in, I see another page ripped out. I went back to the beginning, and saw that someone had neatly torn out the first page of the story. I then went through the book and counted 17 pages torn out of the TPB.

 

WTF??? Someone is a real !!! Now I am out reading this series (for now) and I had the first three trades lined up to read all at once.

 

Buncha savages in this town...

 

:frustrated:

 

 

 

-slym

Link to comment
Share on other sites