• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

What are the rarest romance comics?
33 33

6,447 posts in this topic

I don't think these are particularly rare, but there are 3 copies on the census of Glamorous Romances 55 (very high grade!) and no representation for the others.  There are a handful of Ace painted covers that are on my must-have list and all by the same artist (whom I have yet to identify).  The Love Tales might just be my favorite Colletta cover.

Glamorous Romances 55.JPG

Love at First Sight 3.JPG

Love Tales 72.JPG

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Yorick said:

I don't think these are particularly rare, but there are 3 copies on the census of Glamorous Romances 55 (very high grade!) and no representation for the others.  There are a handful of Ace painted covers that are on my must-have list and all by the same artist (whom I have yet to identify).  The Love Tales might just be my favorite Colletta cover.

Glamorous Romances 55.JPG

 

 

Another Lauren Bacall lookalike. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/10/2018 at 7:45 PM, sagii said:

....Time to put this Thread back on page one. This is a bit of a stretch, but i'm calling this a Romance comic (or cover at least) :sumo:

Spirit Sections (Chicago Sun 10-13-46).jpg

That's awesome.  I'm sure I'm in the boat with everyone else when I say that if these had glossy stock covers they'd be pulling in ridiculous prices.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/10/2018 at 10:45 PM, sagii said:

....Time to put this Thread back on page one. This is a bit of a stretch, but i'm calling this a Romance comic (or cover at least) :sumo:

Spirit Sections (Chicago Sun 10-13-46).jpg

Really cool!  Never seen a copy before that I can remember. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think I only managed to land this one today because it was neither a Chuch copy nor a highest-graded.  But after staring at if for awhile, I put in a proxy bid far above what I ended up paying.  Honestly, it's now one of my favorite romance covers.  I'd even place it up there with the work of the sainted Matt. :whatthe:

Don't know who the artist was.  Maybe @Dr. Love can enlighten us. hm

front_zpscyc3a6g2.JPG

Link to comment
Share on other sites

43 minutes ago, Sqeggs said:

I think I only managed to land this one today because it was neither a Chuch copy nor a highest-graded.  But after staring at if for awhile, I put in a proxy bid far above what I ended up paying.  Honestly, it's now one of my favorite romance covers.  I'd even place it up there with the work of the sainted Matt. :whatthe:

Don't know who the artist was.  Maybe @Dr. Love can enlighten us. hm

front_zpscyc3a6g2.JPG

Congrats!  That's such a great book, was always considered a minor grail of sorts in past years.  Raunchy for a romance book, SOTI, painted, spanking...what more could a collector want?

Don't know the artist though.  I don't think it's lifted it from a paperback or a pulp, Avon experts might know more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

55 minutes ago, Sqeggs said:

I think I only managed to land this one today because it was neither a Chuch copy nor a highest-graded.  But after staring at if for awhile, I put in a proxy bid far above what I ended up paying.  Honestly, it's now one of my favorite romance covers.  I'd even place it up there with the work of the sainted Matt. :whatthe:

Don't know who the artist was.  Maybe @Dr. Love can enlighten us. hm

front_zpscyc3a6g2.JPG

That is a nice one. Congrats on the win.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

59 minutes ago, Dr. Love said:

Don't know the artist though.  I don't think it's lifted it from a paperback or a pulp, Avon experts might know more.

I am no expert but when I matched the ppbs to the comics, I couldn't find a match either.

Here is the list of comics for which I did find a ppb match -

Bad Men of the West # 1

Campus Romance # 2

Campus Romance # 3

Complete Romance # 1

Famous Gangsters # 3

For a Night of Love

Gangsters and Gun Molls # 1

Gangsters and Gun Molls # 3

Intimate Confessions # 1

Intimate Confessions # 2

Intimate Confessions # 3

Intimate Confessions # 4

Intimate Confessions # 6

Intimate Confessions # 8

Jesse James # 6

Jesse James # 7

Murderous Gangsters # 2

Murderous Gangsters # 3

Parole Breakers # 1

Parole Breakers # 2

Police Lineup # 1

Police Lineup # 2

Police Lineup # 3

Prison Break! # 3

Realistic Romances # 4

Realistic Romances # 8

Romantic Love # 1

Romantic Love # 10

Romantic Love # 2

Romantic Love # 6

Romantic Love # 8

Sparkling Love nn (1953)

The Saint # 10

The Saint # 12

The Saint # 7

Wild Bill Hickok # 8

Women to Love nn (1953)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Scrooge said:

I am no expert but when I matched the ppbs to the comics, I couldn't find a match either.

Here is the list of comics for which I did find a ppb match -

Bad Men of the West # 1

Campus Romance # 2

Campus Romance # 3

Complete Romance # 1

Famous Gangsters # 3

For a Night of Love

Gangsters and Gun Molls # 1

Gangsters and Gun Molls # 3

Intimate Confessions # 1

Intimate Confessions # 2

Intimate Confessions # 3

Intimate Confessions # 4

Intimate Confessions # 6

Intimate Confessions # 8

Jesse James # 6

Jesse James # 7

Murderous Gangsters # 2

Murderous Gangsters # 3

Parole Breakers # 1

Parole Breakers # 2

Police Lineup # 1

Police Lineup # 2

Police Lineup # 3

Prison Break! # 3

Realistic Romances # 4

Realistic Romances # 8

Romantic Love # 1

Romantic Love # 10

Romantic Love # 2

Romantic Love # 6

Romantic Love # 8

Sparkling Love nn (1953)

The Saint # 10

The Saint # 12

The Saint # 7

Wild Bill Hickok # 8

Women to Love nn (1953)

That is one nice piece of research there.  Thanks so much, very useful.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Dr. Love said:

That is one nice piece of research there.  Thanks so much, very useful.

Here's the correspondence -

Avon Series # Title Author Comic
114 Sinister Errand Peter Cheyney Parole Breakers # 2
123 The Case of the Dark Hero Peter Cheyney The Saint # 12
143 Flash Casey, Hard-Boiled Detective George Harmon Coxe Gangsters and Gun Molls # 3
156 Pardners of the Badlands Bliss Lomax Jesse James # 6
179 Blondie Iscariot, Siren of the Underworld Edgar Lustgarden Prison Break! # 3
253 Confidential Donald Henderson Clarke Realistic Romances # 4
66 Little Caesar W.R. Burnett Famous Gangsters # 3
222 The Neon Wilderness Nelson Algren Intimate Confessions # 1
151 Where the Girls were different Erskine Caldwell Campus Romance # 2
171 Amorous Philandre Jean-Galli De Bibiena For a Night of Love
456 The Chastity of Gloria Boyd Donald Henderson Clarke Intimate Confessions # 2
201 Strange Desires Len Zinberg Campus Romance # 3
292 Four Boys A Girl and A Gun Willard Weiner Gangsters and Gun Molls # 1
141 Career in C Major James M. Cain Romantic Love # 2
252 A Hell of a Good Time James T. Farrell Romantic Love # 1
252 A Hell of a Good Time James T. Farrell Sparkling Love nn (1953)
118 The Saint in Action Leslie Charteris The Saint # 7
289 Friday for Death Lawrence Lariar The Saint # 10
299 The Round-Up Oscar J. Friend Wild Bill Hickok # 8
173 On the Spot Edgar Wallace Complete Romance # 1
173 On the Spot Edgar Wallace Women to Love nn (1953)
283 She Posed for Death Russel Gordon Parole Breakers # 1
329 Little Caesar W.R. Burnett Police Lineup # 2
120 Alabam' Donald Henderson Clarke Intimate Confessions # 6
250 Carlotta Robert Briffault Intimate Confessions # 3
304 Song Without Sermon James Woolf Intimate Confessions # 4
375 Babes and Sucklings Philip Wylie Intimate Confessions # 8
397 Nina Donald Henderson Clarke Realistic Romances # 8
187 The Love Trap Vina Delmar Romantic Love # 8
207 Virgie Goodbye Nathan Rothman Romantic Love # 6
212 Iron Man W.R. Burnett Romantic Love # 10
306 Gone to Texas John W. Thomas Jr. Bad Men of the West # 1
Murder Mystery Monthly 45 On the Spot Edgar Wallace Police Lineup # 3
Murder Mystery Monthly 46 The Green Ice Murders Raoul Whitfield Police Lineup # 1
Murder Mystery Monthly 47 The Blonder, The Gangster and The Private Eye Dale Clark Murderous Gangsters # 2
Murder Mystery Monthly 48 Murder in her Big Blue Eyes Julius Long Murderous Gangsters # 3
Western Novel Monthly 2 Cattle War Buckaroo William Hopson Jesse James # 7
Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, Sqeggs said:

Well, if you put it that way, I'm afraid I have to disagree. 

...I'm sorry...... I couldn't bear the shame of my mistake :tonofbricks:

GOD BLESS....

-jimbo(a friend of jesus)(thumbsu

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 hours ago, Sqeggs said:

I think I only managed to land this one today because it was neither a Chuch copy nor a highest-graded.  But after staring at if for awhile, I put in a proxy bid far above what I ended up paying.  Honestly, it's now one of my favorite romance covers.  I'd even place it up there with the work of the sainted Matt. :whatthe:

Don't know who the artist was.  Maybe @Dr. Love can enlighten us. hm

front_zpscyc3a6g2.JPG

The source is Rangeland Romances Aug 1949, I believe the artist is Gloria Stoll Karn.

Picture of my copy that needs an upgrade!

 

IMG_5184.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, PeterPark said:

all (worship) to kaizerdawg.  It sold for $1250, but that is still a very very very nice sale for a VG/F copy of an admittedly hard to find book.  Harder than the #1.

 

1 minute ago, GACollectibles said:

The source is Rangeland Romances Aug 1949, I believe the artist is Gloria Stoll Karn.

Picture of my copy that needs an upgrade!

 

IMG_5184.jpg

boom! thanks for the update.  Rangeland Romances are some great pulps.

Edited by Dr. Love
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
33 33